Skip to main content

Top Bar

  • Home |
  • Subscribe |
  • Document Search |
  • Français
|

Main navigation

Logo
  • About the CCAC
    • Vision, Mission, and Mandate
    • The CCAC Program
      • History of the CCAC
    • Governance
      • Board of Directors
      • Standing Committees
      • Member Organizations
    • Reports and Publications
      • Annual Reports
      • Financial Reports
      • Strategic Planning
    • News and Media
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
  • Certification
    • Program Features
      • Oversight
      • Program Fees
    • Certification Process
      • Assessment Visit
      • Assessment Report
      • Implementation Report
    • Certified Institutions
    • Reportable Animal Welfare Incidents
    • Forms and Resources
  • Guidelines & Policies
    • Fundamental Principles
    • Guidelines
      • General Guidelines
      • Animals Guidelines
    • Policies
    • Other Recognized Standards
    • Guidelines in Development
      • Developing Guidelines
      • Forming a Subcommittee
  • Training
    • National Workshops
      • Past Workshops
      • Upcoming Workshop
    • Virtual Learning Series
      • Past Webinars
    • Modules
      • Core
      • Animals Housed in Vivaria
      • Farm Animals
      • Fish
      • Wildlife
    • External Events
  • Animals Used in Science
    • Understanding Animal Use
      • How
      • Who
      • What
      • Where
      • When
      • Why
    • Animal Use Data
      • Animal Use Data Reports
      • Reporting Instructions and Forms
      • Revised Animal Use Data Collection
    • Transparency
      • Transparency Plan
      • Institutional Transparency
      • Transparency Resources
      • Participating Institutions
    • Canadian Legislation and Policies
      • Provincial Information
  • Three Rs
    • Replacement, Reduction, Refinement
    • National and International Three Rs Centres
    • Funding Resources
    • Fellowship Program
  • Volunteers & Awards
    • Volunteer List
    • Recognition Awards
      • Nomination Information
      • Harry C. Rowsell Lifetime Achievement Award
      • Gilles Demers Award for Excellence in Animal Care
      • CCAC Emerging Leader Award
    • Award Recipients
      • Past Lifetime Achievement Award Recipients
      • Past Excellence in Animal Care Award Recipients
      • Past Emerging Leader Award Recipients
About the CCAC
Vision, Mission, and Mandate
The CCAC Program
History of the CCAC
Governance
Board of Directors Standing Committees Member Organizations
Reports and Publications
Annual Reports Financial Reports Strategic Planning
News and Media
Careers
Contact Us
Certification
Program Features
Oversight Program Fees
Certification Process
Assessment Visit Assessment Report Implementation Report
Certified Institutions
Reportable Animal Welfare Incidents
Forms and Resources
Guidelines & Policies
Fundamental Principles
Guidelines
General Guidelines Animals Guidelines
Policies
Other Recognized Standards
Guidelines in Development
Developing Guidelines Forming a Subcommittee
Training
National Workshops
Past Workshops Upcoming Workshop
Virtual Learning Series
Past Webinars
Modules
Core Animals Housed in Vivaria Farm Animals Fish Wildlife
External Events
Animals Used in Science
Understanding Animal Use
How Who What Where When Why
Animal Use Data
Animal Use Data Reports Reporting Instructions and Forms Revised Animal Use Data Collection
Transparency
Transparency Plan Institutional Transparency Transparency Resources Participating Institutions
Canadian Legislation and Policies
Provincial Information
Three Rs
Replacement, Reduction, Refinement
National and International Three Rs Centres
Funding Resources
Fellowship Program
Volunteers & Awards
Volunteer List
Recognition Awards
Nomination Information Harry C. Rowsell Lifetime Achievement Award Gilles Demers Award for Excellence in Animal Care CCAC Emerging Leader Award
Award Recipients
Past Lifetime Achievement Award Recipients Past Excellence in Animal Care Award Recipients Past Emerging Leader Award Recipients

Companion-notes (2).pdf

i CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 1 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science...1 Slide 2 Relevance of this Training Module.........................................................................1 Slide 3 Training Module Goals...........................................................................................2 Slide 4 Training Module Outline.........................................................................................2 Slide 5 What is a Farm Animal?.........................................................................................3 Slide 6 Farm Animal Welfare..............................................................................................4 Slide 7 What is Animal Welfare?........................................................................................4 Slide 8 Regulations & Guidelines Concerning Farm Animals............................................6 Slide 9 A Note on Agricultural Industry Standards.............................................................7 Slide 10 Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs)...............................................................8 Slide 11 Fundamental Needs...............................................................................................9 Slide 12 Feed and Water ....................................................................................................9 Slide 13 The Farm Animal Environment: Why Does It Matter?..........................................10 Slide 14 Housing Requirements.........................................................................................11 Slide 15 Housing Factors Potentially Affecting Welfare.....................................................11 Slide 16 Animal Welfare Effects of Facility Maintenance Issues........................................12 Slide 17 Environmental Improvement................................................................................13 Slide 18 Improving Farm Animal Environments.................................................................14 Slide 19 Environmental Enrichment...................................................................................15 Slide 20 Acquisition............................................................................................................15 Slide 21 Importance of Proper Acquisition.........................................................................16 Slide 22 Transporting Farm Animals for Use in Science....................................................17 Slide 23 Importance of Proper Identification and Animal Record Keeping........................17 Slide 24 Importance of Acclimation....................................................................................18 Slide 25 Quarantine: Essential for Maintaining Good Health and Welfare........................18 Slide 26 Routine Handling and Specialized Procedures....................................................19 Slide 27 Human Contact and Handling..............................................................................20 Slide 28 Effective, Low-Stress Handling............................................................................20 Slide 29 Avoiding Fear Response......................................................................................21 Slide 30 On-Farm Human Safety.......................................................................................21 Slide 31 Restraining Farm Animals....................................................................................22 Slide 32 Minimizing Stress Associated with Restraint........................................................22 Slide 33 Consequences of Restraint Devices....................................................................23 Slide 34 Routine Invasive Procedures and their Effect on Welfare....................................23 Slide 35 Pain Management................................................................................................24 Slide 36 Specialized Procedures.......................................................................................25 Slide 37 Metabolism Crates...............................................................................................26 Slide 38 Meeting Farm Animal Needs in Metabolism Crates.............................................26 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes ii CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 39 Minimizing the Welfare Effects of Blood & Tissue Sampling................................27 Slide 40 Blood Sampling Guidelines..................................................................................27 Slide 41 Blood Volumes: Single Sample............................................................................28 Slide 42 Blood Volumes: Multiple Samples........................................................................29 Slide 43 Surgery................................................................................................................30 Slide 44 Requirements for Major & Non-Survival Surgeries..............................................31 Slide 45 Requirements for Minor & Therapeutic Surgeries................................................31 Slide 46 Fistulation / Catheterization.................................................................................32 Slide 47 Termination of Scientific Use of the Farm Animal................................................32 Slide 48 Endpoints.............................................................................................................33 Slide 49 Return to Herd or Flock........................................................................................33 Slide 50 Emergency Euthanasia........................................................................................34 Slide 51 Disposal of Farm Animals Used in Science.........................................................35 Slide 52 Summary..............................................................................................................36 1 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 1 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science This module provides an introductory overview of the welfare, management and safety factors that relate to the use of farm animals in science. The in- tention is that this overview be utilized in conjunc- tion with hands-on training. Before any research is carried out, all personnel involved must receive practical instruction, and be able to demonstrate competence in all techniques required within the protocol. This training module is based on the CCAC guide- lines on: the care and use of farm animals in research, teaching and testing(2009). Slide 2 Relevance of this Training Module Although this training module focuses on cattle, swine, poultry, sheep and goats, the general princi- ples and considerations outlined in the CCAC guide- lines on: the care and use of farm animals in research, teaching and testing(2009) and this training module also apply to other types of farm animals, including horses and farmed wildlife used in science. CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes 2 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 3 Training Module Goals This training module aims to achieve three goals: 1.To outline the care, housing and handling requirements of farm animals used in sci- ence. Stemming from their origins in the agri- culture production industry, farm animals differ significantly from animals conventionally used in scientific applications (e.g., rodents). Depending on the species and scientific appli- cation, investigators may be faced with animals having unique physiological and behavioural issues and must therefore be prepared to ad- dress the specific needs of the farm animals being utilized. 2.To present an overview of practices that help ensure good welfare of farm animals used in science. Investigators, teachers, animal care per- sonnel and students are presented with basic knowledge of what animal welfare encompasses, and how it relates to animal use responsibilities. Significant focus is given to discussing potential challenges to the welfare of farm animals when used for scientific purposes as well as recommendations for dealing with these challenges. 3.Provide references and resources to more detailed texts, guidelines and training manuals. Where appropriate, hyperlinks have been embedded into the module to provide direct access to the texts and guidelines. References cited in this module are intended to provide direction to further information; however, animal users should consult relevant experts and scientific literature for the most recent information on the species and techniques under consideration. Care has been taken to ensure that any provided web links are up-to-date; however, the dynamic nature of the internet may mean that some links will become out-of-date. Therefore, keyword search suggestions are provided for situations in which links to additional resources may be broken. The keywords can be entered into any standard internet search engine. Slide 4 Training Module Outline Achieving good welfare of farm animals used in science is based largely on understanding the pri- mary components influencing animal welfare as well as adhering to a few basic principles (Re- placement, Refinement and Reduction). Applica- tion of the Three Rs in scientific applications is detailed in section 2.4 of the CCAC guidelines on the care and use of farm animals in research, teaching and testing(2009). Applicable government regula- tions must also be followed in all scientific uses of farm animals. Investigators, teachers, animal care personnel and students should be aware that farm animal welfare 3 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes is impacted by a large number of factors. In the context of this training module, the factors are grouped under the following broad headings: •fundamental needs: providing appropriate feed and water (e.g., quality and quantity), as well as a safe and comfortable environment (e.g., proper management and design of housing systems); •acquisition: following appropriate regulations, guidelines and protocols to ensure proper sourcing, transportation, identification, and good health of new animals; •routine handling and specialized procedures: maintaining appropriate treatment of animals while they are being used in science, including minimizing handling stress and providing pain mitigation as required during procedures; and •termination of scientific use: determining the fate of animals following their use in science and ap- propriate endpoints, as well as planned and emergency euthanasia and animal disposal. The above factors will be considered in more detail throughout the rest of this module. Additional References and Resources: Colditz I.G. (2006) The application of Russell and Burch's Three Rs in commercial livestock experimentation. Animal Welfare15:1–5. Slide 5 What is a Farm Animal? In the context of the CCAC guidelines, the term “farm animal” refers to mammals or birds com- monly kept for agricultural purposes, which in- clude the production of food, fibre, or fertilizer and/or the use of animals for farm work. These an- imals include horses, cattle, sheep, goats, swine, poultry, llamas, alpacas and farmed wildlife such as mink, elk, deer, and bison. 4 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 6 Farm Animal Welfare This section provides the user with a foundation necessary for understanding the care requirements of farm animals used in science by discussing farm animal welfare, the common factors affecting wel- fare, as well as relevant regulations and guidelines. A note is made regarding the application of indus- try standards in a scientific application. Finally, the importance of standard operating procedures (SOPs) is discussed. Slide 7 What is Animal Welfare? Broadly speaking, animal welfare refers to the qual- ity of life experienced by an animal; it is based on three predominant factors – biological functioning (e.g., health status), natural living (e.g., the ability to express natural behaviours), and affective states (i.e., how an animal perceives its present physical, psychological and social situation) (Fraser et al., 1997; von Keyserlingk et al. 2009). The balance among all three factors dictates whether an animal experiences good or poor welfare. For example, a confined farrowing sow may have its nutritional needs met and thus maintains high reproductive productivity (good biological functioning); how- ever, she lacks the ability to move (compromised natural living) and may be distressed due to lack of social contact (negative affective state). Therefore, although the sow has good biological functioning, her welfare is compromised because the other two welfare factors are not being addressed. Biological Functioning Proper biological functioning involves an animal being in good health, free of injury and maintaining desired levels of growth, productivity and reproduction. Investigators should be aware that any factor preventing good biological functioning may not only result in negative animal welfare, but will also impact their re- search results. Investigators can help ensure proper biological functioning by monitoring animals regularly for signs of disease and injury, adhering to a herd/flock health program outlined by a veterinarian, identi- fying and correcting issues in the animals’ housing environment and maintaining the highest possible animal husbandry standards in line with their research objectives. Natural Living For practical and economic reasons, many modern agricultural industry practices do not focus on the con- cept of natural living, making this welfare component the most challenging to understand and implement 5 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes (von Keyserlingk et al., 2009). Nonetheless, investigators should recognize the importance of providing farm animals with an environment that provides opportunity for expression of natural behaviours that are most likely to benefit the animal. See slide 18, “Improving Farm Animal Environments” for an outline of envi- ronmental improvements that may benefit farm animals. Although dependent on species, age, sex, housing and scientific use, promoting aspects of natural living may include more natural eating regimes (e.g., pro- viding sheep grazing forages as opposed to concentrated pellets), opportunity for outdoor exercise (e.g., providing pasture access to laying hens), or materials for nesting where appropriate (e.g., providing far- rowing sows with straw for nest building). Affective States The way an animal perceives its own state impacts its welfare. When an animal experiences negative states (e.g., pain and fear), its welfare is compromised. However, an absence of negative states should be combined with the presence of positive states in order to achieve and maintain good welfare (Yeates and Main, 2008). See Boissy et al. (2007) for a detailed review of positive states and how these states impact welfare. Investi- gators can help promote positive states by providing resources to the animals that provide benefit (e.g., scratching devices to cattle (DeVries et al., 2007)), or by providing opportunity for performance of behaviours the animals are motivated to perform (e.g., group housing calves to accommodate socialization and play behaviour (Jensen and Kyhn, 2000)). Some scientific procedures may result in animals experiencing negative states such as pain and distress (e.g., invasive management and experimental procedures). Investigators are obligated to mitigate such negative states in a manner consistent with good scientific principles. Additional References and Resources: Boissy, A., Manteuffel G., Jensen M.B., Moe R.O., Spruijt B., Keeling L.J., Winckler C., Forkman B., Dimitrov I., Langbein J., Bakken M., Veissier I., and Aubert, A. (2007) Assessment of positive emotions in animals to improve their welfare. Physiology & Behavior92:375–397. DeVries T.J., Vankova M., Veira D.M. and von Keyserlingk, M.A.G. (2007) Short communication: Usage of mechanical brushes by lactating dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science90:2241–2245. Fraser D., Weary D.M., Pajor E.A. and Milligan B.N. (1997) A scientific conception of animal welfare that re- flects ethical concerns. Animal Welfare6:187–205. Fraser D. and Duncan I.J.H. (1998) Pleasures, pains and animal welfare: toward a natural history of affect. Animal Welfare7:383–396. Fraser D. (2008) Understanding Animal Welfare: The Science in its Cultural Context. Oxford UK: Wiley-Blackwell. Jensen, M.B. and Kyhn, R. (2000) Play behaviour in group-housed dairy calves, the effect of space allowance. Applied Animal Behaviour Science67:35–46. von Keyserlingk M.A.G., Rushen R., de Passillé A.M. and Weary D.M. (2009) Invited review: the welfare of dairy cattle—Key concepts and the role of science. Journal of Dairy Science 92:4101–4111. Yeates J.W. and Main D.C.J. (2008) Assessment of positive welfare: A review. The Veterinary Journal175:293– 300. 6 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 8 Regulations & Guidelines Concerning Farm Animals Federal – Transport: Health of Animals Act(Part XII) •The regulations associated with this act outline the conditions necessary for humane transporta- tion of all animals. It prohibits undue suffering caused by transporting sick or injured animals, as well as by continuing to transport animals that become unfit to travel. In addition to designating appropriate types of vehicle design and bedding requirements, the regulations also require that an- imals not be mixed with incompatible individuals and that they not be overcrowded to the point that injury or suffering will result. Maximum times for transportation and feed and water dep- rivation are indicated for different species. •It should be noted that theHealth of Animals Act(Part XII) only addresses the needs of animals during transport, and does not apply to the care and handling of animals outside of transportation situations. •Administered and enforced by the CFIA •http://laws.justice.gc.ca/en/showdoc/cr/C.R.C.-c.296/bo-ga:1_XII/en#anc… Federal – Humane Handling and Slaughter:Meat Inspection Act(Sections 61 – 80) •This act sets standards for the humane handling and slaughter of food animals in federally registered slaughter facilities. It prohibits handling that causes avoidable animal distress and pain, including the use of goads and electric prods on sensitive (anal, genital or facial) regions of the animal. The act also prohibits mixing of different species and addresses the need for food and water prior to slaughter. •Administered and enforced by the CFIA •http://laws.justice.gc.ca/eng/SOR-90-288/page-4.html Federal – Suffering:Criminal Code of Canada(Section 444 – 446) •This federal code prohibits any person from willfully causing an animal to suffer from neglect, pain or injury. Section 444 refers specifically to cattle, whereas sections 445 – 446 are applicable to all other ani- mals, including birds. •Enforced by police forces, societies for the prevention of cruelty to animals (SPCAs) and humane societies. •http://laws.justice.gc.ca/eng/C-46/page-7.html (Note: if any of the above links are broken, search for: Department of Justice Canada and then use the tabs “Statutes by Title”and “Regulations by Title” to locate the specific act or regulation). Federal – Drug and Vaccine Studies •Studies involving the testing of new drugs and vaccines in food animals may require approval from the CFIA or Health Canada. 7 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes •For new vaccines, contact the Veterinary Biologics Section of the CFIA: http://www.inspection.gc.ca/ english/anima/vetbio/vbpbve.shtml (Note: if link is broken, search: CFIA Veterinary Biologics) •For new drugs, contact the Veterinary Drugs Directorate of Health Canada: •     Emergency Drug Release: http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/dhp-mps/vet/edr-dmu/index-eng.php (Note: if link is broken, search: Health Canada Emergency Drug Release) • Experimental Studies Certificate: http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/dhp-mps/vet/applic-demande/form/ esc-cee_08-2002-eng.php (Note: if link is broken, search: Health Canada Experimental Studies Cer- tificate for Veterinary Drug) Provincial and Non-Governmental Organizations •All provinces and territories have legislation governing the care of animals. Numerous non-government organizations also produce recommendations related to the care and use of animals. A summary of the available regulations and guidelines, including details of the individual provincial and non-government organizations’ guidelines can be found at: http://www.inspection.gc.ca/english/anima/trans/infrae.shtml (Note: if link is broken, please search: CFIA Animal Welfare in Canada) •The National Farm Animal Care Council (NFACC) develops voluntary Recommended Codes of Practice for the Care and Handling of Farm Animals. All currently available codes of practice are available from the NFACC website: http://nfacc.ca/code.aspx (Note: if link is broken, please search: NFACC codes). When research must be directly relevant to the agricultural industry, these codes of practice should be used as minimum standards, but require approval by the animal care committee (ACC). Slide 9 A Note on Agricultural Industry Standards It is not appropriate to assume that practices will be acceptable within a research setting just because they are common in agricultural industry. All indus- try standards should be considered as minimums. Furthermore, any deviation from the CCAC guide- lines must be justified to the ACC. •CCAC guidelines on: the care and use of farm ani- mals in research, teaching and testing(2009). Visit the CCAC website at www.ccac.ca to access and consult this guidelines document. General Rule: •Scientific institutions should take a leader- ship role in the adherence to, and the devel- opment of, improved standards that encourage good animal welfare. 8 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 10 Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) Each facility should have SOPs addressing facility management and maintenance. SOPs should also outline all facets of animal care (husbandry, routine invasive procedures, health care, disease preven- tion, etc). Investigators, teachers, animal care per- sonnel and students should be aware of, and comply with, these facility-specific SOPs. It is im- portant for all individuals to be aware of the proce- dures involved in maintaining good farm animal health status. SOPs outlining proper health care practices should include: •practices that minimize disease persistence in the environment (e.g., all-in, all-out animal movement); •routine health checks for groups and individual animals; •welfare assessment of individual animals (complements the welfare assessment methodology outlined in the animal care and use protocol); •management of disease outbreaks within or in nearby facilities; and •drug safety • safe storage and limited access to authorized personnel; • drug and biological use records (see CALAMStandards of Veterinary Care, 2007:http://www.calam- acmal.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/CALAM-Standards-of-Veterinary-Care.pdf) (Note: if link is broken, please search: CALAM standards of veterinary care); • safe disposal of expired drugs, needles and syringes; • management of off-label and extra-label use; and • safe withdrawal and withholding times (Food Animal Residue Avoidance Databank, FARAD: http://www.farad.org) (Note: if link is broken, please search: Food Animal Residue Avoidance  Databank). 9 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 11 Fundamental Needs All farm animals, regardless of their scientific use, have a set of basic requirements that must be met. This includes nutritious and sufficient quantities of feed, ad libitum access to clean, fresh water, as well as safely designed, well-managed housing. The en- vironment must meet animals’ basic needs (provi- sion of space for lying, movement, feeding, etc.), and it should also allow for natural behaviours which animals are highly motivated to perform. Some environmental improvements should be made in order to prevent animal suffering. Further- more, environmental enrichment is strongly en- couraged in order to stimulate farm animals to perform a variety of natural behaviours, including those that may provide pleasure. Slide 12 Feed and Water National Research Council (NRC) guidelines (or other standard texts) should be consulted for species-specific nutritional requirements. Nutrient content of feed should be determined via laboratory analysis, or other acceptable tests. Feed should be palatable, wholesome and nutrition- ally adequate. Research demonstrates that animals are highly motivated to feed upon fresh feed deliv- ery (DeVries et al. 2005). Therefore, feed should be fed in sufficient quantities and frequencies to mini- mize hunger and competition, unless otherwise necessary due to the experimental protocol. Fresh, clean, ice-free water should be available and easily accessible 24 hours a day. The delivery system must have sufficient pressure to meet drinking rates. Investigators should be aware that watering systems need periodic testing. The water itself should be periodically tested to ensure acceptable levels of a variety of factors: pH, sulphates, nitrates, total dissolved solids (TDS), and heavy metals. Testing should also ensure that bacteria (including cyanobacteria), parasites and viruses are not present in harmful quantities. Poor water quality may result in reduced overall wellness and even illness. Additional References and Resources: Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada’s Livestock Water Quality - A Field Guide for Cattle, Horses, Poultry, and Swine: http://www4.agr.gc.ca/AAFC-AAC/display-afficher.do?id=1259101276424&lan… (Note: if link is broken, please search: Agriculture Canada Field Guide Cattle, Horses, Poultry, and Swine) Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment’s Canadian Water Quality Guidelines for the Protection of Agricultural Water Uses: http://ceqg-rcqe.ccme.ca/ (Note: if link is broken, please search: CCME Water Quality Guidelines for the Protection of Agricultural Water Uses) 10 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes DeVries T.J., von Keyserlingk M.A.G., and Beauchemin K.A. (2005) Frequency of Feed Delivery Affects the Behavior of Lactating Dairy Cows. Journal of Dairy Science88:3553–3562. National Research Council (NRC) (1985) Nutrient Requirements of Sheep, 6 th ed. Washington DC: National Academy Press. National Research Council (NRC) (1994) Nutrient Requirements of Poultry, 9 th ed. Washington DC: National Academy Press. National Research Council (NRC) (1998) Nutrient Requirements of Swine, 10 th ed. Washington DC: National Academy Press. National Research Council (NRC) (2000) Nutrient Requirements of Beef Cattle, 7 th ed. Washington DC: National Academy Press. National Research Council (NRC) (2001) Nutrient Requirements of Dairy Cattle,7 th ed. Washington DC: Na- tional Academy Press. Slide 13 The Farm Animal Environment: Why Does It Matter? Except in a case where a new facility is being de- signed and built, investigators typically do not have a great deal of control over the facility design and the nature of animal enclosures. Nonetheless, inves- tigators should still be aware of the key elements of properly designed facilities. How their facility ei- ther complies or deviates from these elements will have a great impact on both human and animal wel- fare, behaviour and security – when these factors are affected, research outcomes can also be affected. In light of preventing negative welfare issues and promoting positive welfare, as well as ensuring the most accurate scientific outcomes, effort should be made to make certain that the design meets the physical, physiological and behavioural needs of the species being housed. A facility should have flexibility to address changes in breed requirements (e.g., dairy breeds have become substantially larger in the past half century) and improvements in housing prac- tices (e.g., group versus individual housing of calves). Investigators should always be aware of the par- ticular shortcomings associated with their facilities and attempt to address these through appropriate husbandry practices in order to limit negative impacts on welfare. Poor animal welfare may impact research outcomes. 11 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 14 Housing Requirements In order to properly address the basic needs of farm animals, facilities should provide: •shelter from adverse weather conditions, includ- ing excess heat and cold, and extreme precipita- tion events (e.g., blizzards, hail, prolonged heavy rain, particularly in cold temperatures); •access to safe, potable water and nutritious, palatable feed; •air quality to maintain good health; •room for exercise, with access to the outdoors (if possible); •space for resting without competition; •urination and defecation area separate from lying and rest area; •space for social contact and interaction, when appropriate (e.g., housing sows in groups rather than individually); and •separate location for specialized needs (e.g., young, sick or quarantined animals). Investigators, teachers, animal care personnel and students should all be aware that in many cases, meeting the physiological and psychological needs of animals requires augmenting the basic housing environment (i.e., environmental improvement). Further improvements to the animals’ environment, termed en- vironmental enrichment are strongly encouraged. For more detailed information regarding the enrich- ment of animal environments: •CCAC training module on: environmental enrichment (2003). Visit the CCAC website at www.ccac.ca to ac- cess and consult this training module. Slide 15 Housing Factors Potentially Affecting Welfare Providing appropriate housing to farm animals used in science is necessary to maintain good ani- mal welfare, which is imperative for accurate scien- tific outcomes. A variety of housing-related factors may impact the welfare of farm animals housed for scientific purposes. •Housing type: farm animal species, climate, available technology and intended use should be deciding factors when choosing housing type; farm animals housed in naturally venti- lated, unheated facilities will have different en- vironmental requirements compared to those housed in mechanically ventilated, heated fa- cilities (e.g., naturally ventilated housing pro- 12 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes vides protection from temperature extremes, but does not provide the climate control of mechanically ventilated facilities). •Space allocation: housing should provide individual animals with space to rest and feed without an excessive amount of competition (e.g. dairy cattle housed in an overstocked free stall environment may experience poorer welfare than cattle provided with one lying spot per animal). •Flooring and footing: materials used in flooring should provide non-abrasive walking surfaces, and should allow for normal movements and postural changes without slipping and/or injury; a common flooring material is concrete because it is easy to clean and sanitize, however it must be used with caution (e.g., prolonged exposure to concrete may cause issues such as lameness); compressible flooring should be used whenever possible in order to reduce the risk of hoof and leg damage. •Lying areas and bedding: species appropriate bedding must be provided as required to provide a dry, comfortable lying surface (e.g., inappropriate bedding type, insufficient quantities of bedding or an in- compatibility of the bedding with the flooring type may increase animal susceptibility to infection and injuries). •Manure handling systems: except in the case of poultry housing systems, it is of utmost importance that animal wastes are separated from animals as soon as possible and are not allowed to buildup in the environment (e.g., both human and animal welfare may be affected if manure is allowed to accumulate, since dangerous gases such as hydrogen sulphide, ammonia and methane may form). •Thermal and non-thermal (air quality) conditions and ventilation systems: maintaining appro- priate air movement, temperature and humidity as well as low noxious gas and dust levels is essential for the health and welfare of both humans and animals (e.g., appropriate ventilation systems are vital for maintaining good indoor air quality). •Lighting intensity and duration: farm animals should never be kept in complete darkness nor should the lights be left on continuously (for suggested lighting levels, please see applicable species-specific modules). Slide 16 Animal Welfare Effects of Facility Maintenance Issues Investigators, teachers, animal care personnel and students should be aware of the SOPs outlining fa- cility maintenance, especially those that cover im- portant system failures. It is essential that vital systems (e.g., feed and water delivery, ventilation, manure removal, etc.) be inspected daily. Both the welfare of animals as well as research out- comes may be negatively impacted if vital sys- tems fail. There should be SOPs in place for dealing with the temporary failure, and investiga- tors should ensure they, as well as any of the per- sonnel involved in their project, are aware of the emergency procedures necessary to maintain good animal welfare. 13 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes The facility manager is responsible for the appropriate upkeep of the facility and should be made aware of any issues immediately.  Additional References and Resources: Guide for the Care and Use of Agricultural Animals in Agricultural Research and Teaching, Third Edition (FASS, 2010): http://www.fass.org/page.asp?pageID=216 (Note: if link is broken, please search: FASS pdf guide for the care and use of agricultural animals in research and teaching) Slide 17 Environmental Improvement Animals perform behaviour patterns based on inter- nal and external stimuli (Hughes and Duncan, 1988). The animal environment should be designed to avoid externally motivated behaviours, like fear re- sponse to predators,and allow the animals to per- form internally motivated behaviours. Examples of means to address internally motivated behaviour is the provision of nesting materials to farrowing sows (Damm et al., 2005), or providing non-nutritive teats to calves (Rushen and de Passillé, 1995). Im- provements to the animals’ environment that ad- dress internally motivated behaviour are encouraged, as the absence of such improvements re- sults in some degree of suffering. Any improve- ments provided should be biologically relevant to the species and development of the animal (e.g., dust bathing material encourages chickens to perform natural dust bathing behaviours). It is particularly important to consider the impact of housing on the welfare of animals in closely controlled situations, such as in biomedical research. The investigator should understand the behavioural needs of the chosen species, and although it may not be possible to address all the needs, consideration should be given towards meeting as many as possible. For instance, if grazing animals are used, they should be given access to feed that mimics their natural foraging behaviour (e.g., feeding sheep pellet-based feed might meet their nutritional requirements, but is quickly consumed and does not meet their natural desire to graze; therefore, the investigator should provide at least some fibrous feed that takes longer to consume). Additional References and Resources: Damm B.I., Pedersen L.J., Heiskanen T. and Nielsen N.P. (2005) Long-stemmed straw as an additional nesting material in modified Schmid pens in a commercial breeding unit: effects on sow behaviour, and on piglet mortality and growth. Applied Animal Behaviour Science92:45–60. Hughes B.O. and Duncan I.J.H. (1988) The notion of ethological 'need', models of motivation and animal welfare. Animal Behaviour36:1696–1707. Rushen J. and de Passillé A.M. (1995) The motivation of non-nutritive sucking calve Bos Taurus. Animal Be- haviour49:1503–1510. 14 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 18 Improving Farm Animal Environments Since scientific (research, teaching and testing) in- stitutions should take leadership roles in maintain- ing high animal care standards, there should be a constant focus towards improving and enriching animal housing. Therefore,investigators should ensure their studies are compliant with high animal care standards, even if a certain level of inconvenience may occur(e.g., welfare advan- tages point to group housing, however blood sam- pling animals housed in this manner may require additional time in order to sample an individual with minimal stress). The following factors should be considered when aiming to provide the best possible housing environment: •physical environment: ensuring appropriate hygiene levels (e.g., providing appropriate bedding type and amount for species), providing comfortable lying and walking surfaces (e.g., provision of a dry lying pack for group-housed goats); •social environment: maintaining appropriate group sizes and compatible social groups (e.g., smaller group size to reduce feather pecking in chickens), as well as considering optimal weaning times from a good animal welfare perspective (e.g., fence-line weaning of beef cattle to promote independence of calves from dams); and •individual animal comfort: encouraging natural behaviours (e.g., providing dust bathing material to hens), minimal isolation and restraint (e.g., free stall housing of pregnant sows), as well as individual lying comfort (e.g., avoiding overstocking of free stall housed dairy cows to ensure all animals can lie concurrently). For examples of environment improvements and enrichments for each species, see applicable species-spe- cific modules. Additional References and Resources: Arey D.S., Petchey A.M. and Fowler V.R. (1991) The preparturient behaviour of sows in enriched pens and the effect of pre-formed nests. Applied Animal Behaviour Science31:61–68. Bilcik B. and Keeling L.J. (1999) Changes in feather condition in relation to feather pecking and aggressive behaviour in laying hens. British Poultry Science40: 444–51. Panivivat R., Kegley E.B., Pennington J.A., Kellogg D.W. and Krumpelman S.L. (2004) Growth performance and health of dairy calves bedded with different types of materials. Journal of Dairy Science87:3736–3745. 15 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 19 Environmental Enrichment Environmental enrichment builds on the concept of environmental improvement. Animals experience pleasure when provided with these specific im- provements. The primary difference is that when absent, improvements deemed to be “environmen- tal enrichments” do not cause the animal to suffer. An example would be scratching devices provided to feedlot cattle (Wilson et al., 2002).Environmen- tal enrichment is strongly encouraged. It should be noted that in order to be effective, en- richment devices should be engaging to the animals for more than a short time. This can be achieved by providing devices that can be manipulated or de- stroyed by the animals. The environment can also be enriched by frequently changing the objects pro- vided, thereby keeping a sense of novelty in the environment. For more detailed information regarding the improvement of animal environments: •CCAC training module on: environmental enrichment (2003). Visit the CCAC website at www.ccac.ca to ac- cess and consult this training module. Additional References and Resources: Wilson S.C., Mitlöhnera F.M., Morrow-Tesch J., Dailey J.W. and McGlone J.J. (2002) An assessment of several potential enrichment devices for feedlot cattle. Applied Animal Behaviour Science76:259–265. Young R.W. (eds.) (2003) Environmental Enrichment for Captive Animals. Oxford UK: Wiley-Blackwell. Slide 20 Acquisition When farm animals are acquired for use in science, a number of factors should be considered. These in- clude properly sourcing the animals, transporting in adherence with regulations and following strict identification protocols. Periods of acclimation and quarantine are necessary before animals can be used in science. 16 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 21 Importance of Proper Acquisition The investigator should be aware of how the acquisition process functions. Animals should only be acquired after a protocol has been approved by the ACC. The investigator should ensure that the animals being acquired meet protocol requirements and should also confirm that facilities are available to house the animals. Animals should only be ob- tained from reputable sources known for their good health management and provision of husbandry and treatment records. Animals should be carefully screened (see slide 25, “Quarantine: Essential for Maintaining Good Health and Welfare”) before being introduced into the main population. The in- vestigator should be aware of the screening process and be able to identify issues with newly intro- duced animals. When sourcing animals, genotype should be considered. Most farm animals have undergone a great deal of genetic selection for specific production traits. However, in some cases this selection has resulted in welfare issues. Example - Fast-Growing Broilers: •selection for quick growth has resulted in increases in leg and cardiovascular problems (Scientific Com- mittee on Animal Health and Animal Welfare, 2000); and •unless using these fast-growing broilers is essential to the experimental protocol, it might be advanta- geous to use a slower growing type of chicken as they are less likely to be affected by these health and welfare issues. Additional References and Resources: Scientific Committee on Animal Health and Animal Welfare. (2000). The Welfare of Chickens Kept for Meat Production (Broilers).149 pp. European Commission, Health & Consumer Protection Directorate-General: http://ec.europa.eu/food/fs/sc/scah/out39_en.pdf (Note: if link is broken, please search: Europe welfare of chickens kept for meat) 17 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 22 Transporting Farm Animals for Use in Science Transportation of all animals, including those being brought to a research facility, must com- ply with federal regulations, and should also fol- low the NFACC’s recommended code of practice. •Part XII of the Federal Health of Animals Regula- tions: http://laws.justice.gc.ca/en/showdoc/cr/ C.R.C.-c.296/bo-ga:l_XII//en (Note: if link is bro- ken, search for: Department of Justice Canada and then use the “Browse Statutes by Title” to the Health of Animals Act.) •Recommended Code of Practice for the Care and Han- dling of Farm Animals – Transportation, 2001: http://www.nfacc.ca/pdf/english/Transporta- tion2001.pdf (Note: if link is broken, please search: NFACC codes and select “Transportation (2001)”) Slide 23 Importance of Proper Identification and Animal Record Keeping A permanent identification system should be in place. Any identification method that is applied directly to the animal (e.g., ear tagging) should be done by a trained individual. Improperly placed identification may result in difficult identification in the future as well as potential injury to the animal (e.g., nerve damage to calves’ ears caused by im- properly applied ear tags). Animal identification should be in accordance with federal and/or provincial guidelines. Some species have specific identification requirements; for instance, in addition to the commonly used ear tags (e.g., easy-to-read feedlot tags), the Canadian Cattle Identification Agency (CCIA) requires that all cattle be tagged with CCIA approved radio-fre- quency identification (RFID) tags. A recording system should include: •individual records: birth date, sex, pedigree, origin, physical measurements, reproductive information, and health, medical and nutritional history; and •experimental records: protocol number, principal investigator, emergency contact information, and summary of experimental procedure (all located near enclosures). Full research activity records should be kept to ensure that an animal’s experimental treatment in one study does not impact its response to treatment in subsequent study.  18 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Additional References and Resources: CFIA’s Livestock Traceability Information: http:// ww.inspection.gc.ca/english/anima/trac/trace.shtml (Note: if link is broken, please search: CFIA livestock) CCIA’s Cattle Identification Information: http://www.canadaid.com/ (Note: if link is broken, please search: CCIA cattle) Slide 24 Importance of Acclimation Before farm animals are used in science, they should be acclimated to experimental condi- tions; it is preferable to accomplish the acclimation and quarantine periods together. The time required for acclimation will be heavily dependent on species, age, previous housing conditions, feeding regime and any treatments given prior to arrival. For suggested acclimation time periods, please see applicable species-specific modules. The acclimation duration will depend greatly on the amount of environmental change imposed. For instance, animals accustomed to group housing will adjust to individual housing fairly quickly, espe- cially if pre-conditioning occurs in a step-wise fash- ion (e.g., increase the duration of isolation over a period of days). However, when animals are moved from outdoor housing to indoor, controlled environmental conditions, there will be a longer acclimation time needed. Changes in ambient conditions will typically lead to physiological changes and may require special husbandry procedures (e.g., sheep may initially hyperventilate when moved indoors, but clipping them will help in the acclimatization process). Other considerations include the need to introduce dietary changes and increased human handling gradually, as well as the need to carefully structure new social groups. Acclimation will also be necessary when transitioning animals back to outdoor conditions. Slide 25 Quarantine: Essential for Maintaining Good Health and Welfare The purpose of a quarantine period is to pro- tect the health of animals within a facility by isolating new animals of unknown health sta- tus or ill animals already in the population. In- vestigators must ensure that the animals they are using are subject to a quarantine period, by coordi- nating with the farm/facility manager and the herd/flock veterinarian. The length of time for quar- antine is dependent on the species and the antici- pated timeframe for pathogen expression; quarantine duration should be established in con- sultation with the herd/flock veterinarian. Once an- imals are deemed healthy, they can be integrated into the facility population. Quarantined animals need to be monitored very carefully and detailed 19 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes records made at least twice daily of any changes in feeding patterns, water intake as well as general behav- iour and appearance. If there is any doubt about an animal’s condition, its body temperature should also be monitored. Records acquired during quarantine may be important to the investigator if health concerns arise during the experimental period. Quarantine areas should be managed according to rigorous infectious agent control practices, which include: •security fences, entry alarms and signage; •separate animal housing areas, with provision for external observation of animals; •limiting visitor access, or when not possible, imposing a physical boundary between visitors and animals; •removal of organic debris from footwear paired with sufficient contact time with germicidal footbaths, as well as plastic footwear covers, hand washing stations, shower-in/shower-out, and clothing changes; •dedicated ventilation systems, air filters and equipment; •dedicated storage for feed and bedding; •clean to dirty traffic flow; and •physical protection between contained animals and wildlife, pests and predators. For more details, see the CCAC training module on: occupational health and safety(2003). Visit the CCAC website at www.ccac.ca to access and consult this training module. There should be an established SOP outlining these practices, including effluent treatment when applicable. Investigators should be aware of the procedures outlined within the SOP. Slide 26 Routine Handling and Specialized Procedures Farm animals used in science may be exposed to nu- merous handling, testing, sampling and other rou- tine and invasive procedures over the course of their lives. Investigators, teachers, animal care personnel and students should be aware of how to properly conduct procedures, as well as how each type of pro- cedure affects the welfare of animals involved. 20 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 27 Human Contact and Handling Human-animal contact has a large impact on ani- mal welfare. An animal is likely to perceive a nega- tive handling experience fearfully. When an animal is fearful its stress responses increase, and subse- quently, its welfare is reduced. Reduced welfare may manifest itself in many ways including (but not limited to) altered behaviour and reduced produc- tivity. In the context of scientific applications and research, poor animal welfare may result in altered and/or biased research results. Therefore, when an- imals are handled positively, it not only benefits the animal, but also the research. Slide 28 Effective, Low-Stress Handling Effective and low-stress handling of farm ani- mals stems from proper training and experi- ence. Investigators should ensure that they, as well as all personnel involved in their project, are famil- iar with: •species-specific animal behaviour; •animal herding and flight zones; and •techniques required to safely and calmly handle, lift, move and herd animals. Stress related to handling activities can be greatly reduced by personnel working within the natural behavioural responses of the animals (e.g., when a herd animal requires treatment, removing it from its group with one or two conspecifics will reduce isola- tion-based fear). Where applicable, conditioning animals to routine handling should be considered, as it will reduce animals’ natural fear response, in turn helping personnel to maintain consistent, positive han- dling techniques. Electric prods must be severely restricted, and only be used when not doing so will place the animal under additional stress or risk. 21 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 29 Avoiding Fear Response Evidence exists that negative handling can have long-term physiological impacts on animals (e.g., Hemsworth and Barnett, 1991; Rushen et al., 1999). Animals are able to recognize and remember individual people, and will respond fearfully to those that have treated them negatively in the past. It is important to note that fear is not just produced by rough handling, it also occurs when handlers move quickly, shout or use electric prods. An ani- mal’s ears, tail or legs should not be pulled. Fear re- actions are easily reduced when handlers use slow and calm approach methods, including scratching and stroking when close enough to do so. Further- more, since animals recognize individuals and recall previous treatment, it is important for personnel to handle animals in a consistent manner. Personnel who are positive and consistent in their animal handling will find that animals will respond less fearfully over time, thus making handling situations less stressful for both animals and humans. Additional References and Resources: Hemsworth P.H., and Barnett J.L. (1991) The effects of aversively handling pigs either individually or in groups on their behaviour, growth and corticosteroids. Applied Animal Behaviour Science30:61–72. Rushen J., de Passillé A.M., and Munksgaard L. (1999) Fear of people by cows and effects on milk yield, be- havior, and heart rate at milking. Journal of Dairy Science82:720–727. Slide 30 On-Farm Human Safety In the past decade, the fifth highest cause of on-farm deaths was animal-related. Of these on-farm deaths related to working with animals, the most common occurred during: 1.herding; 2.feeding and watering; and 3.inspecting and veterinary procedures. It is very important for everyone working with animals to identify potential safety hazards. Ef- fective procedures, such as SOPs and training, must be implemented to assess and control identified hazards and risks. Of particular importance are proper animal restraint methods that minimize injury. Additional References and Resources: Canadian Agricultural Injury Reporting (http://cair-sbac.ca/tecrep.html) (Note: if link is broken, please search: CAIR-SBAC) 22 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Handling Farm Animals Safely. (Farm Safety Association, 2002): http://nasdonline.org/document/44/ d001612/handling-farm-animals-safely.html (Note: if link is broken, please search: NASD handling farm an- imals safely) On-Farm Safety Manuals: Protect Yourself from Livestock Injuries(Nova Scotia Department of Agriculture, 2004): http://www.gov.ns.ca/agri/farmsafety/livestock/index.shtml (Note: if link is broken, please search: farm safety protect yourself from livestock injuries) Slide 31 Restraining Farm Animals Handling and restraint of animals should be done using species-appropriate equipment and facilities. Restraint devices should not be used for rou- tine housing. Where there is a need to use these devices for prolonged periods, this use must be ap- proved by the ACC. Some larger farm animals may pose a threat to the welfare of conspecifics as well as handlers. To mini- mize the impact of their behaviour, restraint devices such as hobbles, squeeze chutes and stanchions, may be utilized. However, only the minimum amount of restraint necessary to control the animal should be used. Electro-immobilization is highly aversive and in- duces paralysis without providing any anesthetic or analgesic effects. Electro-immobilization must not be used. Slide 32 Minimizing Stress Associated with Restraint When restraint of an animal is required, the focus should always be to use the least amount of re- straint necessary in order to ensure animal and han- dler safety. Many farm animals can be gradually conditioned to restraint devices, particularly with the use of food rewards. Training animals to co- operate with treatments and the associated re- straint devices and procedures minimizes stress for the animals even in the case of more prolonged and frequent bouts of restraint. 23 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 33 Consequences of Restraint Devices Even the best-designed restraint devices will have negative impacts on the animals, particu- larly when they are used for extended periods. In addition to potential psychological/behavioural impacts, physical issues may include (but are not limited to): contusions, knee/hock abrasions, horn damage, extensive feather loss, ulcers, dependent edema (fluid accumulation in lower or dependent parts of the body), lameness, joint injuries and weight loss. Investigators are responsible for mon- itoring the animals for signs of these problems, and should be prepared to administer treatment accord- ingly. The animal care and use protocol should make provisions for such treatment, including the temporary or permanent removal of the animal from the restraint device. Such treatment and their endpoints must be clearly defined in the protocol and approved by the ACC. •CCAC guidelines on: choosing an appropriate endpoint in experiments using animals for research, teaching and testing (1998). Visit the CCAC website at www.ccac.ca to access and consult this guidelines document. Typically many physical consequences of restraint devices are due to long-term restraint. Investigators should keep this in mind when designing their protocols; unless scientifically justified within the experi- mental protocol, prolonged restraint must be avoided. Additional References and Resources: Guide for the Care and Use of Agricultural Animals in Agricultural Research and Teaching, Third Edition (FASS, 2010): http://www.fass.org/page.asp?pageID=216 (Note: if link is broken, please search: FASS pdf Guide for the Care and Use of Agricultural Animals in Research and Teaching) Slide 34 Routine Invasive Procedures and their Effect on Welfare Many routine and accepted agricultural prac- tices are known to cause temporary and chronic pain (e.g., dehorning, branding, castration, beak trimming, and tail docking). Investigators are encouraged to use alternative practices, minimize invasiveness of the procedures and use analgesics and anesthetics, when appropri- ate. Any routine invasive procedures that have po- tential to cause temporary or chronic pain must be described in an ACC approved SOP accompanying the experimental protocol. Scientific institutions should encourage investigation of alternative meth- ods in an effort to establish the best agriculture practices. As research develops improved practices, SOPs should be updated accordingly. 24 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Although considered routine management practices by agricultural industry, procedures such as dehorning and castration are minor surgeries; therefore, investigators should ensure their protocol makes provisions for appropriate and safe analgesic use before the procedure, sedative and/or anesthetic use during the pro- cedure, and post-operative pain mitigation following the procedure (see slide 35, “Pain Management”). In- vestigators should be aware that some routine invasive procedures might have long-term negative impacts on the animals(e.g., calves castrated with the rubber ring method show indicators of chronic pain, including leg stamping, licking, abnormal standing and decreased growth rate for weeks following the procedure (Molony et al., 1995; Thuer et al., 2007)). Painful or distressing procedures, or ones that may be harmful physically, psychologically and socially, can- not be justified by indicating they are commonly practiced commercially. Such practices can only be justified if the use of agricultural industry practices is essential to the scientific research outcomes, and should never be used to demonstrate to students a procedure that is otherwise not recommended. Additional References and Resources: Molony V., Kent J.E. and Robertson I.S. (1995) Assessment of acute and chronic pain after different methods of castration of calves. Applied Animal Behaviour Science46:33–48. Thuer S., Mellema S., Doherr M.G., Wechsler B., Nuss K. and Steiner A. (2007) Effect of local anaesthesia on short- and long-term pain induced by two bloodless castration methods in calves. The Veterinary Journal 173:333–342. Slide 35 Pain Management All procedures capable of causing pain (e.g., minor and major surgeries, routine invasive pro- cedures, etc.) should be accompanied with ap- propriate pain management. This may include sedatives and anesthetics during the procedure and analgesics prior to and following the procedure. Dur- ing the development of the protocol, the potential for pain associated with the planned procedures should be identified. It is important to note that not all pain control options are suitable for all proce- dures and farm animal species, and a veterinar- ian should be consulted to ensure an appropriate pain mitigation program is developed. Personnel knowledgeable in the identification of post-procedural pain, distress and/or discomfort should monitor the animals frequently. If concerns are identified, prompt pain relief must be provided. Pain management should also be included in the herd/flock health program SOP. Local anesthetics are only useful for short-term application. Other longer-term pain mitigation strategies should be planned. The pain mitigation strategy should be developed by a veterinarian in order to ensure that it is appropriate for the procedure and the species. Additional References and Resources: Flecknell P.A. and Waterman-Pearson A. (eds.) (2000) Pain Management in Animals. London UK: WB. Saun- ders/Elsevier Inc. 25 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 36 Specialized Procedures In addition to the care and attention already out- lined for farm animals being used in scientific ap- plications, many experimental conditions involving specialized procedures which require additional care and monitoring; these include: •metabolic crates; •blood and tissue sampling; •major and minor surgeries; •fistulation/catheterization; •biomedical research (see the CCAC training mod- ule on: farm animals used in biomedical research (2010)); and •genetic engineering (see the CCAC training module on:genetically-engineered farm animals (2010)). Consideration should be given to the necessity of performing specific procedures, as well as the availability of less invasive alternatives (e.g., using other bodily fluids such as milk instead of blood to sample hormones or metabolites). All handling and sampling will have both behavioural and physiological impacts on the animal, which may in turn impact research results; therefore, effort should be made to min- imize the impact of handling. One of the most effective means of lowering associated procedural stress is to precondition animalsto the procedures prior to the commencement of the experiment. This may include a gradual introduction to restraint devices, coupled with food rewards or may simply involve accustoming the animals to handling by specific personnel. All specialized procedures require separate SOPs detailing additional husbandry, nutrition and other re- quirements, with particular attention paid to animal pain and distress. It is the responsibility of investigators to ensure any personnel caring for these animals are properly trained and are familiar with the relevant SOPs. Veterinarians involved in the care of the animals should have access to detailed records of all procedures, as early identification and treatment of problems is imperative for maintaining good animal welfare. It should be every investigator’s goal to use as few animals as possible while maintaining statistically valid results. This is particularly applicable in cases where animals are exposed to pain and/or distress. In certain cases it may be appropriate to re-use animals rather than subjecting new animals to a procedure. For in- stance, if a scientific application requires the use of rumen fistulated ruminants, it is preferable to use pre- viously fistulated animals, rather than performing the procedure on new animals. However, in teaching situations, the instructor should consider the pedagogical merit of performing procedures on the same an- imal; reducing the number of animals utilized is encouraged, but consideration must be given towards how many times a procedure can humanely be performed on a single animal. 26 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 37 Metabolism Crates Metabolism crates may be required in nutrition and physiology studies to facilitate the collection of urine, feces and respiratory gases as well as to pro- tect catheters and cannulae. These crates can se- verely restrict the ability of animals to move up and down and side to side. Although movement is heavily restricted, space must be adequate both in height and length to allow the animals to eat, rise and rest normally, as well as to main- tain a comfortable posture. Due to their restric- tive nature, structural integrity and maintenance of the metabolism crates are extremely important in order to prevent injury. Cleanliness is very impor- tant and crates should be sanitized on a weekly basis. Animals will have varying reactions to the confining nature of metabolism crates, and consideration must be given to individual adjustment. In particular, animals housed in groups prior to the commencement of the experiment may become distressed, making preconditioning to the crates a necessary step. The experi- mental protocol should provide for this preconditioning period; it is typically a minimum of five days in length, but is subject to the discretion of the ACC. The effects of confinement and isolation can be at least partially addressed by allowing for visual, auditory and olfactory contact with conspecifics. Crates should be positioned in a manner to ensure animals will have such contact; if necessary, animals not included in the study should be housed in the same room to ease the distress associated with isolation. Slide 38 Meeting Farm Animal Needs in Metabolism Crates Farm animals, particularly herding species, are adapted towards heat sharing with conspecifics. Their tolerance for lower temperatures is impacted when they are housed alone. The absence of bed- ding will exacerbate this effect. Therefore, investi- gators should ensure personnel caring for animals in metabolism crates are trained to identify the signs of thermal distress; provisions should exist for alleviating the negative consequences of any environmental stressors animals might ex- perience. Monitoring of thermal stress indicators should be included in an SOP. Metabolism crates are approved for short-term use only, and should never be used as perma- nent housing. The maximum total experiment time should not exceed two months. Animals must be provided with a 24-hour opportunity to exercise every seven days; however, this time may be adjusted based on professional judgment, ACC approval and adherence to the welfare of individual animals. Frequent monitoring and assessment of behavioural and body condition is necessary and should be used in evaluating the welfare of the animals. 27 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 39 Minimizing the Welfare Effects of Blood & Tissue Sampling Blood and tissue sampling are invasive and require significant interaction between humans and the farm animals involved. All invasive procedures and handling can be stressful. Proper training for personnel, preconditioning of animals, and using remote sampling when possible can min- imize animal stress during sampling. Anesthetic use should be considered depending on restraint method, physical condition of animal and the amount of blood and/or tissue required. Investigators should remember that the attending veterinarian is an essential part of the research team and can provide valuable insight into how sam- pling impacts animals. The veterinarian should be consulted when deciding on the most appropriate sampling methodology. Slide 40 Blood Sampling Guidelines The general sampling rule is to never take more than 10% of the blood volume; however, it is impor- tant to consider how much blood is actually needed. Only the amount needed to achieve experimen- tal goals should be sampled, not the maximum possible. Prolonged blood sampling places animals at risk of developing anemia; therefore, animals should be closely monitored throughout the procedure. When multiple blood samples are required, cannulation should be considered. Using the smallest effective diameter minimizes discomfort. To keep the site open for repeated sampling, the cannulae should be flushed regularly with anticoagulant solution. If cannulae are to be in place for long periods and the animal must be restrained, the merit of keeping cannulae open should be balanced with the potential welfare impact of long-term restraint. Upon removal of cannulae, the animal must be closely monitored for signs of irritation, infection and sep- ticemia. Monitoring for signs of anemia should continue as well. Septicemia: •abrupt increases or decreases in body temperature; •rapid breathing; •low blood pressure; and •decreased feed intake. 28 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Anemia: •lowered haematocrit indicates dropping red blood cell counts. Additional References and Resources: Morton D.B., Abbot D., Barclay R., Close B.S., Ewbank R., Gask D., Heath M., Mattic S., Poole T., Seamer J., Southee J., Thompson A., Trussell B., West C. and Jennings M. (1993) Removal of blood from laboratory mammals and birds. First Report of the BVA/Frame/RSPCA/UFAW Joint Working Group on Refinement. Laboratory Animals 27:1–22. Slide 41 Blood Volumes: Single Sample Maximum single blood sample volumes based on body weight have been established for each species (Table 1). To obtain the maximum volume that can be sam- pled in a single bleed for a specific animal, multiply the one bleed maximum (ml/kg) in Table 1 by the animal’s weight (kg). Example #1: 0.8 kg chicken(methodology on slide 41, “Blood Volumes: Single Sample”) Example #2:30 kg pig 6.6 ml/kg x 30 kg = 198 ml one bleed max Additional References and Resources: Sampling methodology adapted from: Hawk C.T., Leary S.L. and Morris T.H. (2005) Formulary for Labo- ratory Animals, 3 rd ed. Ames IA: Blackwell Publishing. Mitruka B.M. and Rawnsley H.M. (1977) Clinical, Biochemical and Haematological Reference Values in Normal Experimental Animals. Tunbridge Wells UK: Abacus Press. Species Bleed Max (ml/kg) Cattle 7.7 Goat 6.6 Sheep 6.6 Pig 6.6 Chicken 9.9 Table 1: Maximum single blood volume samples Adapted: Mitruka and Rawnsley, 1977. 29 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 42 Blood Volumes: Multiple Samples To calculate the maximum volume when perform- ing multiple bleeds, the blood volume mean per kilogram (Table 2) is used in conjunction with ani- mal weight and frequency of re-sampling. Multiply the appropriate blood volume mean in Table 2 by the animal weight, to calculate the total blood volume. Then multiply the total blood vol- ume by the percent of blood removed (correspond- ing to recovery time) (Table 3). Example #1: 40 kg goat, sampled every 2 weeks (methodology on slide 42, “Blood Volumes: Multi- ple Samples”) Example #2: 30 kg pig sampled every week 65 ml/kg x 30 kg = 1950 ml total blood volume 1950 ml x 7.5% = 146 ml per sample Additional References and Resources: Altman P.L. and Ditmer D.S. (1974) The Biology Data Book, 2 nd ed. Bethesda MD: Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology. Diehl K.H. Hull R., Morton D., Pfister R., Rabe- mampianina Y., Smith D., Vidal J.M. and van de Vorstenbosch C. (2001) A good practice guide to the administration of substances and removal of blood, including routes and volumes.Journal of Applied Toxicology21:15–23. Sampling methodology adapted from: Hawk C.T., Leary S.L. and Morris T.H. (2005) Formulary for Labo- ratory Animals, 3 rd ed. Ames IA: Blackwell Publishing. Morton D.B., Abbot D., Barclay R., Close B.S., Ew- bank R., Gask D., Heath M., Mattic S., Poole T., Seamer J., Southee J., Thompson A., Trussell B., West C. and Jennings M. (1993) Removal of blood from laboratory mammals and birds. First Report of the BVA/Frame/RSPCA/UFAW Joint Working Group on Refinement. Laboratory Animals 27:1–22. Species Blood volume mean (range) ml/kg Cattle 57 (52-61) Goat 70 (57-89) Sheep 66 (60-74) Pig 65 (61-68) Chicken 60 Table 2: Mean blood volume per species Adapted from Altman and Dittmer (1974) and Morton et al. (1993) Recovery time before next sampling (weeks) Blood removed (% of total blood volume) 1 7.5% 2 10% Table 3: Percent blood removed based on recovery time Adapted from Diehl et al. (2001) 30 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 43 Surgery The welfare of the animal should be a primary con- cern during all surgical procedures; even in the case of non-survival surgeries, proper pre-operative treatment and anesthesia practices are essential for maintaining good animal welfare. Therefore, surgi- cal procedures are to be performed by experienced and competent individuals only. Minor surgery refers to surgical procedures which do not puncture the body cavity and which create lit- tle or no physical or physiological impairment (e.g., wound suturing or peripheral vessel cannulation). Major surgery consists of any procedure that results in any of the following: •penetration or direct access to a major body cavity, such as the cranium, spinal canal, thorax, abdomen or pelvis; •exposure of major vascular, muscular, skeletal, neural, lymphatic or glandular structures; •substantial impairment to physical or physiological functioning; and •removal or alteration of a functionally significant amount of tissue. Animals undergoing major surgery require significant care prior to, during and, in the case of survival sur- gery, following the procedure. Personnel caring for farm animals involved in major surgeries must have special training, in line with SOPs describing the necessary skills required to care for animals involved. In particular, personnel should be skilled in the early identification of any potential concerns associated with the surgery, so remedial treatment can be administered as quickly as possible. Additional References and Resources: Detailed information about most common surgical techniques in cattle, goats, sheep and swine: Fubini S.L., and Ducharme N. (eds.) (2007) Farm Animal Surgery. New York NY: Inc. Canadian Council on Animal Care (1993)CCAC Guide to the Care and Use of Experimental Animals, vol. 1, 2 nd ed. Ottawa ON: CCAC. 31 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 44 Requirements for Major & Non-Survival Surgeries In addition to their invasiveness, surgeries are clas- sified according to their end result: •survival: animal recovers from anesthesia; and •non-survival: animal is euthanized prior to re- covery from anesthesia. Any major survival surgery should be performed in surgery-specific facilities, following standard asep- tic surgical procedures. This includes the use of sur- gical caps, masks, gowns, sterile gloves and equipment. To prevent septic conditions impacting research outcomes, any long (over 30 minutes) non- survival surgeries should also follow strict aseptic surgical procedures. For short, non-survival surgeries, strict aseptic standards do not need to be met, however equipment and surgery area should be clean. Detailed records should be kept for all surgeries. Animals undergoing a major, survival surgery for research purposes (e.g., not a major emergency surgery) should only do so once in their lifetime, unless scientifically justified within the protocol. Slide 45 Requirements for Minor & Therapeutic Surgeries Minor surgeries (e.g., wound suturing) may be per- formed under less stringent conditions (compared to major surgeries), providing standard veterinary practices are followed. Therapeutic and emergency surgeries (e.g., caesar- ian sections, bloat treatment, correcting displaced abomasums, etc.) often need to be performed in standard agricultural settings; however, sanitary and aseptic techniques should be used as much as possible. The animal’s welfare is of utmost impor- tance; therefore, pain mitigation (sedatives, anes- thetics and analgesics) must be used appropriately. Within a research setting, two surgical situations occur – planned surgery (where the surgery itself is being studied) and emergency surgery (where the research conducted may or may not be a factor in trig- gering the condition requiring surgery). When emergency surgeries are highly probable within a specific scientific application, details of the surgeries must be included in the protocol. Required materials (e.g., emergency sanitary surgical packs) should be prepared prior to the commencement of the research activity. 32 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 46 Fistulation / Catheterization Fistulated or catheterized farm animals require special care in addition to the requirements for other farm animals used for scientific pur- poses. Investigators must ensure their protocol out- lines special care requirements and references any applicable SOPs. These SOPs must cover estab- lished endpoints for the removal of catheters, and complications that may arise. Personnel should be trained in the necessary additional care required of fistulated and catheterized animals, including ini- tial post-operative monitoring and appropriate maintenance and care of the devices. Any animals with implanted telemetry devices must be clearly identified so they can be monitored for short and long-term complications. For the safety of both an- imals and humans, animals should be restrained during the catheterization process, as well as during sampling. A review by Harmon and Richards (1997) covers the various approaches of gastrointestinal fistulation of ruminants. The authors discuss the materials used in, and the placement of, five cannula types (Reentrant, Simple-T, Closed-T, Omasal, and Abomasal). Suggestions are made as to which cannula types are best suited for various applications. The size of fistulae used should be appropriate for the application; larger sizes may impact rumen contraction and feed passage (Hirayamaa and Katoh, 2005). Investigators should carefully consider what type of cannula would best meet protocol requirements. Additional References and Resources: Harmon D.L. and Richards C.J. (1997) Considerations for gastrointestinal cannulations in ruminants. Journal of Animal Science75:2248–2255. Hirayamaa T. and Katoh K. (2005) Effects of fistula size on rumen internal pressure and passage rate of feed in goats. Small Ruminant Research56:277–280. Slide 47 Termination of Scientific Use of the Farm Animal All animal care and use protocols must outline the fate of animals following scientific use, how end- points are determined as well as euthanasia methodology specific to the species and experi- ment. The disposal of animal carcasses should also be considered, particularly when food chain dis- posal is not an option. 33 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 48 Endpoints An endpoint is the point at which the pain and/or distress experienced by an animal is ter- minated, minimized or reduced by stopping a procedure, providing treatment for the pain and distress or euthanizing the animal.  Choosing the earliest endpoint compatible with the scientific objectives of the approved protocol will alleviate or minimize the pain, distress or discom- fort experienced by the animals. The veterinarian and the ACC should be involved in the selection of endpoints. The CCAC provides guidelines to assist in the se- lection of appropriate endpoints: •the CCAC guidelines on: choosing an appropriate endpoint in experiments using animals for research, teaching and testing(1998). Visit the CCAC website at www.ccac.ca to access and consult this guidelines document; and •section 9.6 in CCAC guidelines on: the care and use of farm animals in research, teaching and testing (2009). Visit the CCAC website at www.ccac.ca to access and consult this guidelines document. These guidelines summarize monitoring procedures as well as the use of pilot studies for determining end- points. Also discussed are the specifics for frequency of observation, the responsibilities of personnel and the ACC, as well as examples of endpoint determination in specific types of research. Slide 49 Return to Herd or Flock In many instances, particularly when scientific use is non-invasive (e.g., evaluating play behaviour of group housed dairy calves), farm animals may be reintroduced into a previously existing herd or flock upon the end of their scientific use. De- pending on the species, age, sex, housing and new group size, some farm animals may find readjust- ment difficult; animals should be monitored closely upon reintroduction. The principles outlined in slide 24, “Importance of Acclimation” apply when animals are being returned to the main farm animal population. Records of all treatments to which the animals are exposed should be kept to ensure past scientific use does not impact future scientific use. 34 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 50 Emergency Euthanasia The euthanasia of farm animals not entering the food chain must be performed in accordance with CCAC guidelines on: euthanasia of animals used in sci- ence (in prep.). SOPs must be developed for emergency, on-farm euthanasia and disposal situations. These should include: •animals that cannot be moved to slaughter facilities; •prevention of animal suffering due to un-reliev- able pain and/or distress; and •emergency disease control. The intention of euthanasia is to make the animal’s death as distress-free and painless as possible. The most important criteria for acceptance of a euthanasia method is that it have a rapid initial depressive action on the central nervous system to ensure immediate insensitivity to pain, and that steps are taken to minimize fear and psychological stress in the animal prior to the procedure. There should be SOPs outlining euthanasia methods that will cause the least distress and pain to the animal. The methods used should be suited to the species, age and health status of the animal. When possible, the animal should be euthanized in its home environment, as moving and mixing animals creates further stress and increases the chances of disease transmission. If restraint is necessary in order to carry out euthanasia safely, personnel should be knowledgeable in han- dling and restraint practices that minimize fear, distress, injury and pain; if restraint methods will cause these aversive states, tranquilizers, sedatives and anesthetics must be considered. Developing the emergency disease control SOP will allow for evaluation of euthanasia methods which min- imize pain, distress and disease spread, as well as provide consideration for the individuals required to carry out the procedures. Personnel must be properly trained to perform the methods of euthanasia outlined in the SOPs. Training should include: •recognizing animal pain and distress using behavioural measures; •safe and stress-minimizing handling and restraint techniques; •performing the euthanasia procedure (including the preferred method, as well as an alternative method); •recognizing and assessing unconsciousness; and •accurate confirmation of death. Species-specific methods are outlined in the subsections of Section 10 in CCAC guidelines on: the care and use of farm animals in research, teaching and testing(2009). Additionally, see applicable species-specific CCAC training modules (to come in 2011). Visit the CCAC website at www.ccac.ca to access and consult this guide- lines document and training module. 35 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes Slide 51 Disposal of Farm Animals Used in Science Food Chain Disposal In some cases, farm animals used in science are ac- cepted into the food chain. Standard withdrawal periods must be followed when any commonly uti- lized antibiotics or hormones have been adminis- tered. It should be noted that cannulated and fistulated animals are not usually suitable for food chain disposal. Animals that are accepted into the food chain should be transported according to standard federal regulations and national recommended codes of practice (see slide 22 “Transporting Farm Animals for Use in Science”). Although investigators do not have control over how animals are slaughtered off-site, investigators can en- sure that the slaughter facilities to which animals are sent comply with humane slaughter practices, use ap- proved methods, and comply with the following acts and regulations: •Agriculture Canada’s Meat Inspection Act R.S., 1985 c.25 [1 st Supp.]: http://laws.justice.gc.ca/eng/SOR-90- 288/page-4.html; •Federal Health of Animals Act, 1990 c.21: http://laws.justice.gc.ca/en/showdoc/cr/C.R.C.-c.296/bo-ga:l_ XII//en; and •provincial legislation, municipal and local by-laws. (Note: if any of the above links are broken, search for: Department of Justice Canada and then use the “Browse Statutes by Title” to locate specific act and regulation.) Additionally, the national industry Recommended Codes of Practice for the Care and Handling of Farm Animals (http://www.nfacc.ca/code.aspx) should be followed. (Note: if link is broken, please search: NFACC codes) Non-Food Chain Disposal Farm animals used in scientific applications testing new drugs and vaccines, or that have been challenged by pathogens or radioisotopes are typically not allowed into the food chain (either as food, or rendered food by-product). The reasoning for this is two-fold. First, potential exists for pathogen contamination. Second, the media which new vaccines and pathogens are grown on is not always certified free of Transmissible Spongiform Encephalopathies (TSEs). Both these reasons make the animals unsuitable food sources. How- ever, if the previous situations can be avoided, it is possible to receive approval for food chain disposal in some cases, by contacting the appropriate regulatory bodies: •for new vaccines: Veterinary Biologics Section of the CFIA: http://www.inspection.gc.ca/english/ anima/vetbio/vbpbve.shtml (Note: if link is broken, search: CFIA veterinary biologics); •for new drugs: Veterinary Drugs Directorate of Health Canada •     Emergency Drug Release: http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/dhp-mps/vet/edr-dmu/index-eng.php (Note: if link is broken, search: Health Canada emergency drug release); and 36 CCAC training module on: the ethical use and care of farm animals in science Companion Notes • Experimental Studies Certificate: http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/dhp-mps/vet/applic-demande/form/esc- cee_08-2002-eng.php (Note: if link is broken, search: Health Canada experimental studies certificate for veterinary drugs). Investigators should be aware of and comply with the stipulations for appropriate and legal disposal routes for carcasses containing drugs and radioisotopes; SOPs should be followed closely to prevent such carcasses from entering the food chain. Contingency plans should be in place to address the disposal of animals when the primary disposal route is not available (e.g., failure of incinerator or digester). In some cases, temporary storage of animals (e.g., freezing) while a disposal route is found may be necessary, and should therefore be planned for in advance. Slide 52 Summary The purpose of this training module was to provide individuals working with farm animals in science an introduction to the care, housing, and handling practices which promote good welfare. The key to- wards effectively meeting farm animal needs in a welfare-focused manner is to understand that good welfare stems from three components: bi- ological functioning, natural living and affec- tive states. All three factors must be balanced in order to achieve good farm animal welfare. Balance can be achieved by ensuring the fundamental needs of the animals are met, and by focusing on appro- priate husbandry and treatment before, during and after their use in science. Animal users should strive to achieve their sci- entific goals in line with the best possible animal welfare standards. 

Companion-notes (2).pdf
CCAC Logo

Canadian Council On Animal Care

Important Notices

Contact Us

LinkedIn

Quick links

  • Home
  • About
  • Certification
  • Training
  • Animals Used in Science
  • Guidelines & Policies
  • Three Rs
  • Volunteers and Awards

Get In Touch

  • Location

    190 O’Connor St, Suite 800
    Ottawa, ON, K2P 2R3

  • Email

    ccac@ccac.ca

  • Phone

    613–238–4031


© 2005–2026 - Canadian Council On Animal Care - All Rights Reserved