CCAC policy statement nience must not take precedence over the animal's physical and mental well-being. 3. Expert opinion must attest to the potential value of studies with animals. The follow- ing procedures, which are restricted, require independent, external evaluation to justify their use: i) burns, freezing injuries, fractures, and other types of trauma investigation in anesthetized animals, concomitant to which must be acceptable veterinary practices for the relief of pain, includ- ing adequate analgesia during the recovery period; ii) staged encounters between predator and prey or between conspecifics where prolonged fighting and injury are probable. 4. If pain or distress is a necessary concomi- tant to the study, it must be minimized both in intensity and duration. Investiga- tors, animal care committees, grant review committees and referees must be especial- ly cautious in evaluating the proposed use of the following procedures: a) experiments involving withholding pre and post-operative pain-relieving medication; b) paralyzing and immobilizing experi- ments where there is no reduction in the sensation of pain; c) electric shock as negative reinforcement; The use of animals in research, teaching, and testing is acceptable onlyif it promises to contribute to understanding of fundamental biological principles, or to the development of knowledge that can reasonably be expect- ed to benefit humans or animals. Animals should be used only if the researcher's best efforts to find an alternative have failed. A continuing sharing of knowl- edge, review of the literature, and adherence to the Russell-Burch "3R" tenet of "Replace- ment, Reduction and Refinement" are also requisites. Those using animals should employ the most humane methods on the smallest number of appropriate animals required to obtain valid information. The following principles incorporate sugges- tions from members of both the scientific and animal welfare communities, as well as the organizations represented on Council. They should be applied in conjunction with the Canadian Council on Animal Care's (CCAC) Guide to the Care and Use of Experimental Animals: 1. If animals must be used, they should be maintained in a manner that provides for their physical comfort and psychological well-being, according to CCAC's policy statement on: social and behavioral require- ments of experimental animals. 2. Animals must not be subjected to unneces- sary pain or distress. The experimental design must offer them every practicable safeguard, whether in research, in teaching or in testing procedures; cost and conve- Ethics of Animal Investigation Canadian Council on Animal Care Conseil canadien de protection des animaux 2 d) extreme environmental conditions such as low or high temperatures, high humidity, modified atmospheres, etc., or sudden changes therein; e) experiments studying stress and pain; f) experiments requiring withholding of food and water for periods incompati- ble with the species specific physiologi- cal needs; such experiments should have no detrimental effect on the health of the animal; g) injection of Freund's Complete Adjuvant. This must be carried out in accordance with CCAC guidelines on: acceptable immunological procedures. 5. An animal observed to be experiencing severe, unrelievable pain or discomfort should immediately be humanely killed, using a method providing initial rapid unconsciousness. 6. While non-recovery procedures involving anesthetized animals, and studies involv- ing no pain or distress are considered acceptable, the following experimental procedures inflict excessive pain and are thus unacceptable: a) utilization of muscle relaxants or para- lytics (curare and curare-like) alone, without anesthetics, during surgical procedures; b) traumatizing procedures involving crushing, burning, striking or beating in unanesthetized animals. 7. Studies such as toxicological and biologi- cal testing, cancer research and infectious disease investigation may, in the past, have required continuation until the death of the animal. However, in the face of dis- tinct signs that such processes are causing irreversible pain or distress, alternative endpoints should be sought to satisfy both the requirements of the study and the needs of the animal. 8. Physical restraint should only be used after alternative procedures have been fully considered and found inadequate. Animals so restrained must receive excep- tional care and attention, in compliance with species specific and general require- ments as set forth in the Guide. 9. Painful experiments or multiple invasive procedures on an individual animal, con- ducted solely for the instruction of students in the classroom, or for the demonstration of established scientific knowledge, cannot be justified. Audio-visual or other alterna- tive techniques should be employed to con- vey such information. Canadian Council on Animal Care 1510-130 Albert Street Ottawa ON Canada K1P 5G4 Tel.: (613) 238-4031 Fax: (613) 238-2837 E-mail: ccac@ccac.ca Website: http://www.ccac.ca For more information on these and other policies contact: revised October 1989
Ethics_of_animal_investigation.pdf