CCAC guidelines: Wildlife Canadian Council on Animal Care Conseil canadien de protection des animaux CCAC CCPA Date of Publication: March 2023 © Canadian Council on Animal Care, 2023 ISBN: 978-0-919087-97-2 190 OâConnor St., Suite 800 Ottawa, Ontario, K2P 2R3 http://www.ccac.ca ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The Canadian Council on Animal Care (CCAC) Board of Directors is grateful for the expertise contributed by the members of the CCAC Subcommittee on Wildlife and for their engagement throughout the guide- lines development process. In addition, the Board is grateful to all those who provided critical input during the two review periods. We would also like to acknowledge the contributions of both the CCAC Standards Committee and the CCAC Assessment and Certification Committee members, who provided important guidance to the subcommittee. Finally, we would like to thank the CCAC Secretariat project team for its excellent work throughout this process. The CCAC also acknowledges its funders, the Canadian Institutes of Health Research and the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada. The CCAC could not continue to deliver on its current mandate without their support. Dr. Michael Czubryt Chair, CCAC Board of Directors Mr. Pierre Verreault CCAC Executive Director CCAC WILDLIFE SUBCOMMITTEE Dr. Nigel Caulkett (Chair), University of Calgary Dr. Sherri Cox, University of Guelph Dr. Sara Dubois, British Columbia Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Dr. Kyle Elliott, McGill University Ms. Lesley Howes, Environment and Climate Change Canada Dr. Evelyn Merill, University of Alberta Dr. Stacey Robinson, Environment and Climate Change Canada and Carleton University Dr. Gregory Schmaltz, University of the Fraser Valley Ms. Andree Shore, University of Toronto Animal Care Committee Dr. Owen Slater, University of Calgary Dr. Lianna Zanette, University of Western Ontario NENA DAKâANUTA â TAKING CARE OF ANIMALS "Who does the term âWildlifeâ refer to? Many First Nations people say, âAll My Relationsâ. My grandchildren are seven generations from first contact. Since then, how have we changed how we see animals? We have now given ourselves authority over animals. By stating these kinds of guidelines, we are assuming authority over animals.â (Gùdia- Mary Jane Johnson, Lhuâà à n Mân Ku DaÅ Elder, Whitehorse, Yukon, December 2021). The definition of âWildlifeâ used in this document is colonial. While the CCAC guidelines were developed to minimize suffering and negative effects on wildlife imposed by research and researchers, the guidelines are limited to the perspectives and contexts represented by those who were and are authorized to create, review, and enact them. They are limited to western, colonial contexts and perspectives. The deep, holistic knowledge of wildlife held by First Nations, Inuit, and Métis peoples is not reflected in this version of animal care guidelines. Future versions must go far beyond and instead be built on an entirely new foundation that includes First Nation, Inuit, and Métis Knowledges. We must consider many questions, including: âHow would the guidelines and the actions of researchers be different if we always thought of effects seven generations ahead? How would the guidelines be different if we thought of âwildlifeâ as one of our Earth relatives? How do we want our actions to reflect respect of other beings, our relations? How did we get here, where animals are seen as experimental units in a scientific study, and where animals can be collared and tattooed without even talking to people who see those animals as relations, as food, and as beings who deserve gratitude and respect? How do we want to move forward from here?â (Gùdia â Mary Jane Johnson, Lhuâà à n Mân Ku DaÅ Elder, Whitehorse, Yukon, December 2021). At first we were wary of writing an introduction to this version of the wildlife care guidelines because we did not want to appear as if we endorsed the guidelines as currently written. However, we welcomed the opportunity to stress the importance of including First Nation, Inuit, and Métis worldviews. In particular, we emphasize the need for individual researchers to assume responsibility for their actions, and in taking ac- tions of Reconciliation with First Nations, Inuit, and Métis peoples in their research. Protocols for handling and studying animals that respect Indigenous Knowledges will vary greatly among communities. It is the responsibility of the researcher to reach out and learn these protocols, understand them, and respect them. We thank CCAC staff and Board of Directors for inviting us to write these introductory words as a start towards Reconciliation with Indigenous peoples in this aspect of science. Elder Gùdia â Mary Jane Johnson Kluane First Nation Dr. Heidi Swanson University of Waterloo Dr. Carmen Wong Parks Canada Table of Contents CCAC guidelines: Wildlife i TABLE OF CONTENTS PREFACE.........................................................................................................................1 LIST OF GUIDELINE STATEMENTS IN THIS DOCUMENT............................................2 1. INTRODUCTION......................................................................................................10 1.1 Engagement with Indigenous Communities and Organizations......................................10 1.2 Definition of Wildlife and Scope of the Guidelines.............................................................10 1.3 The Three Rs.............................................................................................................................11 1.4 Considerations for Animal Care Committees.....................................................................12 2. SCIENTIFIC ACTIVITIES CONDUCTED IN THE FIELD.........................................14 2.1 General Considerations..........................................................................................................14 2.2 Protocols Involving Wildlife...................................................................................................18 2.3 Morbidity and Mortality in the Field....................................................................................20 2.4 Personnel Involved in Field Activities ..................................................................................20 3. OBSERVATIONAL FIELD ACTIVITIES...................................................................22 3.1 General Considerations..........................................................................................................22 3.2 Observational Activities Involving Manipulation of Wildlife Environments..................23 4. CAPTURE.................................................................................................................24 4.1 General Considerations..........................................................................................................24 4.2 Physical Capture.......................................................................................................................26 4.2.1 Monitoring Frequency...............................................................................................27 4.3 Chemical Capture....................................................................................................................27 4.3.1 Muscle Relaxants.........................................................................................................28 4.3.2 Drug Delivery..............................................................................................................29 5. HANDLING AND RESTRAINT.................................................................................31 5.1 Handling....................................................................................................................................32 5.2 Physical Restraint.....................................................................................................................32 5.3 Chemical Restraint..................................................................................................................33 5.3.1 Training........................................................................................................................34 Table of Contents CCAC guidelines: Wildlife ii 5.3.2 Pharmacological Considerations..............................................................................34 5.3.3 Monitoring, Supportive Care, and Recovery..........................................................35 5.3.4 Drug Residues.............................................................................................................36 6. KILLED SPECIMENS...............................................................................................38 7. MARKING OF ANIMALS..........................................................................................40 7.1 General Considerations..........................................................................................................40 7.2 Visible Identification Marks...................................................................................................41 7.3 Telemetry Devices....................................................................................................................42 7.4 Tissue Marking (Invasive)......................................................................................................43 8. BIOLOGICAL SAMPLING AND SURGERY............................................................45 8.1 Collection of Biological Samples............................................................................................45 8.1.1 Blood and Tissue Samples.........................................................................................46 8.2 Use of Analgesics......................................................................................................................46 8.3 Physiological Measurements..................................................................................................47 8.4 Surgery......................................................................................................................................47 9. TRANSPORTATION.................................................................................................49 9.1 Transportation by Road or Air ..............................................................................................49 10. HOUSING AND HUSBANDRY ................................................................................51 10.1 Housing.....................................................................................................................................51 10.2 Nutrition...................................................................................................................................53 10.3 Social Interactions....................................................................................................................53 10.4 Health........................................................................................................................................53 10.5 Hygiene .....................................................................................................................................54 11. WELFARE ASSESSMENT.......................................................................................55 11.1 Application of Welfare Assessments and Reporting...........................................................55 11.2 Welfare Indicators....................................................................................................................56 11.2.1 Health Indicators........................................................................................................56 11.2.2 Behavioural Indicators...............................................................................................57 11.2.3 Physiological Indicators.............................................................................................57 Table of Contents CCAC guidelines: Wildlife iii 12. RELEASE OF ANIMALS..........................................................................................59 12.1 Release of Animals Following Procedures............................................................................59 12.2 Scientific Activities Involving Translocation of Animals....................................................59 12.2.1 Animal Welfare Considerations ...............................................................................60 12.2.2 Behavioural Considerations for Release..................................................................61 12.2.3 Environmental and Population Considerations at the Release Site.....................61 13. EUTHANASIA...........................................................................................................63 13.1 Methods of Euthanasia............................................................................................................64 13.1.1 Pharmaceutical Methods...........................................................................................64 13.1.2 Inhalant Gases.............................................................................................................65 13.1.3 Physical Methods........................................................................................................66 13.2 Unacceptable Methods of Euthanasia...................................................................................67 13.3 Disposal of Euthanized Animals............................................................................................68 14. HUMAN SAFETY CONSIDERATIONS....................................................................69 REFERENCES................................................................................................................70 APPENDIX 1 REGULATORY AGENCIES AND RELEVANT LEGISLATION..................................78 APPENDIX 2 WILDLIFE GUIDELINES PUBLISHED BY OTHER ORGANIZATIONS...................84 GLOSSARY....................................................................................................................85 Preface CCAC guidelines: Wildlife 1 PREFACE The Canadian Council on Animal Care (CCAC) is the national peer-review organization responsible for setting, maintaining, and overseeing the implementation of high standards of ethical care and use of animals in science throughout Canada. The CCAC guidelines: Wildlife provides information for investigators, study directors, instructors, animal care committees, and veterinarians to help facilitate improvement in both the care given to wildlife and how procedures are carried out. Where conditions required by scientific activities differ from the guidelines, they must be justified to, and approved by, the animal care committee. The individual guideline statements in the document have been developed based on expert peer advice and current interpretation of scientific evidence. CCAC guidelines are intended to provide a framework for implementing Russell and Burchâs Three Rs: replacement, reduction, and refinement (Russell and Burch, 1959), primarily the principle of refinement. These practices are constantly evolving, and refinements should result in continual improvement in animal welfare. For studies outside of Canada, investigators based at CCAC-certified institutions are subject to these guidelines and the relevant legislation and regulations pertaining to ethical animal care and use in the country where the scientific activity is conducted. Wildlife List of Guideline Statements in This Document CCAC guidelines: Wildlife 2 LIST OF GUIDELINE STATEMENTS IN THIS DOCUMENT The following list of guideline statements serves as an executive summary covering the most important as- pects of the care and use of wildlife. These guideline statements are included within this document alongside details and references that provide support and context for their implementation. Throughout this docu- ment, the term âshouldâ is used to indicate an obligation for which any exceptions must be justified to and approved by an animal care committee. The term âmustâ is used for mandatory requirements. 1. INTRODUCTION Guideline 1 Scientific activities that do not interfere with the animal in any way (e.g., observations from a distance that are unlikely to affect normal behaviour) should be prioritized over more intrusive approaches. Section 1.3 The Three Rs, p.12 2. SCIENTIFIC ACTIVITIES CONDUCTED IN THE FIELD Guideline 2 Scientific activities conducted in the field must be designed with the welfare of the animals in mind and to minimize disturbance of the animals and their habitat. Section 2.1 General Considerations, p.14 Guideline 3 If conducting a scientific activity in the field is likely to have lasting negative effects on a local animal population or to affect the persistence of an animal population or ecosystem, the investigator must demonstrate that the scientific activity is necessary. When such impacts are likely, the scientific activity should not be undertaken except under extraordinary circumstances, as approved by the animal care committee. Section 2.1 General Considerations, p.16 Guideline 4 Consultation and involvement of veterinarians with wildlife experience should be sought on projects involving potential animal health and welfare concerns and, in some cases, must be sought where procedures can be performed or drugs prescribed (e.g., medically important antimicrobials), only by a veterinarian. Section 2.1 General Considerations, p.17 Guideline 5 When morbidity is observed during or following handling or manipulation, the situation should be investigated and documented, and refinements of protocols should be addressed in protocol updates or List of Guideline Statements in This Document CCAC guidelines: Wildlife 3 amendments. Mortalities should receive a postmortem to determine the cause of death, with the results included in the annual report to the animal care committee at the time of protocol renewal. Section 2.3 Morbidity and Mortality in the Field, p.20 3. OBSERVATIONAL FIELD ACTIVITIES Guideline 6 Investigators should ensure observational activities minimize disturbance to the animals and their habitat. Section 3.1 General Considerations, p.22 Guideline 7 When manipulation of the animalâs environment is necessary for a scientific activity, the investigator must make every effort to select the most appropriate method of observation for the species that will minimize stress to avoid distress and ensure the survival of the animals. Section 3.2 Observational Activities Involving Manipulation of Wildlife Environments, p.23 4. CAPTURE Guideline 8 Before initiating field projects involving capture, investigators should be familiar with the sensitivity and tolerance of the target and non-target species to methods of capture and restraint. Every effort must be made to minimize stress to avoid distress and ensure the welfare of the captured animal. The post-handled animal should be comparable to non-handled animals in terms of such factors as reproductive success, behaviour, and survival. Section 4.1 General Considerations, p.24 Guideline 9 Investigators conducting scientific activities in the field that involve capture must be prepared to handle reasonably anticipated conditions that may cause undue stress or injury to the animal. Section 4.1 General Considerations, p.25 Guideline 10 Investigators must be prepared to recognize and respond to animals injured as a result of their actions and euthanize those suffering unrelievable pain or distress if they are not expected to survive when released and cannot be rehabilitated. Section 4.1 General Considerations, p.26 List of Guideline Statements in This Document CCAC guidelines: Wildlife 4 Guideline 11 Investigators must specify monitoring requirements for traps and nets in the protocol, and these must be appropriate to the capture method and target species to minimize stress to avoid distress in the captured animals, and to avoid injury or death. Section 4.2.1 Monitoring Frequency, p.27 Guideline 12 Investigators must make an effort to minimize the risks associated with drugs used for and during capture. As always, the animalâs welfare must be the primary consideration, taking into account human safety. Section 4.3 Chemical Capture, p.27 Guideline 13 Depolarizing muscle relaxants (e.g., succinylcholine chloride) cause paralysis without anesthesia and must be used with an anesthetic agent. Section 4.3.1 Muscle Relaxants, p.28 Guideline 14 Investigators must ensure the remote drug delivery systems for administering anesthetic agents to free- ranging wildlife are appropriate for the size of the animal and for the volume of drug to be administered and are used based on established protocols. Section 4.3.2 Drug Delivery, p.29 5. HANDLING AND RESTRAINT Guideline 15 Personnel handling animals must be competent in the proposed procedures, alternative methods of restraint that may be required, and the use of sedatives or work under the direct supervision of competent personnel. Section 5.1 Handling, p.32 Guideline 16 Within the limits of human safety, effective methods of physical restraint that minimize the possibility of physical injury and physiological and psychological stress must be used, and restraint should be for the shortest possible time necessary for the procedures being undertaken to be completed. Section 5.2 Physical Restraint, p.32 Guideline 17 When morbidity is observed in an animal during or following chemical restraint, it must be addressed. Following completion of the procedure, morbidities must be investigated and documented to refine and improve protocols. Any mortality during or following chemical restraint should receive a postmortem to determine the cause of death. Section 5.3 Chemical Restraint, p.33 List of Guideline Statements in This Document CCAC guidelines: Wildlife 5 Guideline 18 Personnel performing or supervising chemical restraint on wildlife must be competent and must use techniques and drugs that are appropriate for the target species. Section 5.3.1 Training, p.34 Guideline 19 Drugs used for the immobilization of wildlife should have the following properties: be stable in solution, be effective in small volumes, produce minimal deleterious physiological or toxicological effects, result in rapid onset, and be reversible. When painful procedures are to be undertaken, anesthesia and analgesia must be provided. Section 5.3.2 Pharmacological Considerations, p.34 Guideline 20 Appropriate supportive care and close monitoring must be provided during chemical immobilization to minimize the risk of morbidity or mortality and ensure animals can recover and be safely released. Section 5.3.3 Monitoring, Supportive Care, and Recovery, p.35 Guideline 21 Investigators must take all possible steps to ensure that drugs used in procedures on wildlife do not enter the food web. Section 5.3.4 Drug Residues, p.36 6. KILLED SPECIMENS Guideline 22 Lethal methods for collection of wildlife must be species-specific and humane. Personnel involved with administering lethal termination must be competent in the proposed method(s) or under the direct supervision of personnel competent in the method(s) to ensure effective, humane death. p.38 7. MARKING OF ANIMALS Guideline 23 Investigators must aim to minimize all short-term and long-term adverse effects of the marking procedures and the marks on the animals. Section 7.1 General Considerations, p.40 List of Guideline Statements in This Document CCAC guidelines: Wildlife 6 Guideline 24 When considering the use of visible marks, investigators must weigh the requirements of the scientific activity against the potential risks of morbidity, mortality, or altered behaviour or reproduction of the animals, and minimize these risks. Section 7.2 Visible Identification Marks, p.41 Guideline 25 Telemetry devices and their attachment materials should be as light weight and as streamlined as possible for the species on which they are deployed. Investigators should use devices that minimize discomfort and hindrance of normal behaviour, health, or other aspects of the animalâs welfare. Section 7.3 Telemetry Devices, p.42 Guideline 26 Marking techniques that cause significant tissue injury, such as branding and toe and tail clipping, must not be used unless based on evidence that the procedure is necessary and alternative methods cannot achieve the required results. Section 7.4 Tissue Marking (Invasive), p.44 8. BIOLOGICAL SAMPLING AND SURGERY Guideline 27 Investigators should use the least invasive method of collecting biological samples from the animal that is suited to the goals of the scientific activity. Section 8.1 Collection of Biological Samples, p.45 Guideline 28 Sampling of blood and other tissue, including tooth extraction, must be performed only by, or under the direct supervision of, personnel competent in the procedures, and must avoid or minimize pain and distress. Section 8.1.1 Blood and Tissue Samples, p.46 Guideline 29 Appropriate analgesics should be used for any procedure that may produce pain. Section 8.2 Use of Analgesics, p.46 Guideline 30 Investigators must consult a veterinarian on projects involving surgical interventions, including laparotomies, transmitter implants, and other invasive procedures that expose the abdominal cavity or other deep tissues. In some cases, procedures can be performed only by a veterinarian according to relevant laws governing the practice of veterinary medicine. Section 8.4 Surgery, p.47 List of Guideline Statements in This Document CCAC guidelines: Wildlife 7 9. TRANSPORTATION Guideline 31 Investigators must ensure that the care, containment, and mode of transportation of wildlife are suitable for the species and the animalâs condition, based on the best available information for that species or similar species, and that the animal will be transported in a manner that minimizes stress and injury. p.49 10. HOUSING AND HUSBANDRY Guideline 32 Investigators must review the literature and seek expert advice to gain an understanding of the relevant requirements, habits, and behaviours of any wildlife species to be held captive. p.51 Guideline 33 Animals held for up to 24 hours must be placed in appropriate containment that allows adequate ventilation and be provided with suitable food, water, and furnishings (e.g., bedding for mammals and perches for birds and other species), based on the length of time they are being held. Section 10.1 Housing, p.51 Guideline 34 A captive environment for the long-term (>24 hours) confinement of wildlife must provide for any anticipated behavioural, physical, nutritional, and security needs, while providing enrichment opportunities for physical and psychological stimulation. Section 10.1 Housing, p.52 Guideline 35 Diet and feeding schedules should reflect the animalâs normal foods and feeding behaviour. Section 10.2 Nutrition, p.53 Guideline 36 Social relationships and social behaviour of captive wildlife must be taken into consideration when designing and maintaining captive facilities for wildlife populations. Section 10.3 Social Interactions, p.53 Guideline 37 Facility setup and cleaning routines should be designed to maintain adequate hygiene levels while minimizing disturbance of the animals. Section 10.5 Hygiene, p.54 List of Guideline Statements in This Document CCAC guidelines: Wildlife 8 11. WELFARE ASSESSMENT Guideline 38 The welfare of all wild animals involved in scientific activities must be assessed according to a plan that is suited to the type of scientific activity and designed to optimize the collection of information without adding procedures that would cause stress for the animal. p.55 12. RELEASE OF ANIMALS Guideline 39 Translocation must be justified for an individual, population, or species, taking into consideration the impacts on the source and recipient populations and ecosystems. The possible negative consequences of translocation on the individual animal, source and recipient populations, and the ecological conditions at the release site must be considered and mitigated and minimized within the constraints of the scientific activity. When translocation occurs, the health and disease status of the source and recipient populations and the individuals to be translocated must be evaluated prior to translocation. Capture, transportation, and release of translocated individuals must follow current best practices for animal welfare, and individuals should be released to maximize their ultimate survival and minimize impacts on other species and the environment. Section 12.2 Scientific Activities Involving Translocation of Animals, p.59 Guideline 40 Appropriate measures must be taken to ensure the welfare and humane treatment of animals throughout all stages of translocation. Section 12.2.1 Animal Welfare Considerations, p.60 Guideline 41 Investigators should be confident that the habitat at the proposed release site can provide for the speciesâ requirements for survival and reproduction, and that no impairment to the ecological integrity of the site will occur as a result of the release. Section 12.2.3 Environmental and Population Considerations at the Release Site, p.61 13. EUTHANASIA Guideline 42 A method of euthanasia that minimizes pain and distress should be chosen and be suited to the objectives of the scientific activity. Consideration should also be given to techniques that least interfere with postmortem analysis. p.63 List of Guideline Statements in This Document CCAC guidelines: Wildlife 9 Guideline 43 The euthanasia method that has minimal impacts on other wildlife and the ecosystem should be chosen. Any animal euthanized in the field that may contain residues of toxic euthanasia chemicals or other drugs (e.g., potent opioids, antibiotics, or anti-inflammatories) or substances (e.g., lead shot) known to have impacts on other wildlife and the ecosystem should be disposed of in such a manner that contaminated tissues do not enter the food web or water sources. Section 13.3 Disposal of Euthanized Animals, p.68 Section 1 Introduction CCAC guidelines: Wildlife 10 1 INTRODUCTION Throughout this document, the term âmustâ is used for mandatory requirements. The term âshouldâ is used to indicate an obligation, for which any exceptions must be justified to, and approved by, an animal care committee. 1.1 ENGAGEMENT WITH INDIGENOUS COMMUNITIES AND ORGANIZATIONS This revision of the CCAC guidelines on: the care and use of wildlife (CCAC, 2005) is intended to provide updated guidance on practices commonly used in scientific activities involving wildlife, in line with ad- vances in animal welfare. The CCAC recognizes the need for engagement with Indigenous communities and organizations in further revision of this document. Consultation with Indigenous communities and orga- nizations has not yet taken place; however, the CCAC acknowledges the importance of incorporating and respecting Indigenous worldviews and protocols as outlined in Towards Reconciliation: 10 Calls to Action to Natural Scientists Working in Canada. As a first step to meaningfully contribute to reconciliation, enable and improve wildlife research, and help avert potential misunderstandings with Indigenous communities, investigators and animal care committees are encouraged to learn and be respectful of Indigenous protocols within the communities associated with proposed wildlife studies. 1.2 DEFINITION OF WILDLIFE AND SCOPE OF THE GUIDELINES For the purposes of this document, wildlife refers to free-ranging and captive wild vertebrates and cepha- lopods, including amphibians, reptiles, birds, and mammals, while excluding fish (see the CCAC guidelines on: the care and use of fish in research, teaching and testing (CCAC, 2005)). This includes all introduced and native species and domestic animals that have become feral. It does not include domestic animals that have been transported to a wildlife setting for the purpose of in situ research (this situation is addressed in other CCAC guidelines for particular types of animals). The present guidelines focus on free-ranging wildlife and wild-caught animals that have not been habituated to captivity. The CCAC guidelines: Husbandry of animals in science (CCAC, 2017) must be consulted where wild animals are to be maintained in animal facilities over a period of time that is likely to significantly impact successful reintroduction back into their native environment. The CCAC requires animal care committee approval of protocols for scientific activities involving animals in accordance with the Requirement for submitting an animal protocol: Addendum to the CCAC policy statement on terms of reference for animal care committees (CCAC, 2020). Section 1 Introduction CCAC guidelines: Wildlife 11 For animal-based activities that fall within the CCACâs mandate but do not require animals be included in a protocol, such as observational activities in which there is no expected impact on the animals or those around them, investigators must still inform the animal care committee for confirmation that the activity does not require an animal protocol (CCAC, 2020). Guidance on the conduct of observational activities in the field is provided in this document (Section 3, âObservational Field Activitiesâ) because it is difficult to account for inadvertent disturbances that may occur from the presence of an observer or remotely operated equipment, and a protocol may be required. 1.3 THE THREE RS These guidelines are necessarily broad and are limited to basic principles that will assist investigators and an- imal care committees in the development and review of protocols and standard operating procedures (SOPs) specific to scientific activities involving wildlife (see the CCAC policy statement on: terms of reference for ani- mal care committees (CCAC, 2006) for information to be included in a protocol form). As with any animal- based scientific activity, the scientific validity of a protocol involving wildlife must be established carefully, and the Three Rs (replacement, reduction and refinement) (Russell and Burch, 1959) must guide decisions concerning the design of the scientific activity and the care of wildlife when conducting procedures. Animals may be used only if the researcherâs best efforts to find a non-animal replacement or a method that does not interfere with the animal (e.g., a non-invasive method such as camera traps, scat collection, or use of tracks) to obtain the required information have failed. Where the use of animals is necessary, consideration must be given to the substitution of non-cephalopod invertebrates for vertebrates or cepha- lopods. It is recognized that where the aim of a scientific activity in the field is to understand the ecology, ecophysiology, or behaviour of wildlife, replacement by a non-animal-based method, or even replacement of one species with another, may not be an option (Griffin and Gauthier, 2004). However, there may be op- portunities to minimize contact with animals to obtain the data required for the scientific activity (e.g., en- vironmental DNA (eDNA) (Thomsen and Willerslev, 2015; Neice and McRae, 2021), genetic non-invasive sampling (gNIS) (Schultz et al., 2021), hair traps, remote imaging, and data banks). In addition, research involving endangered or threatened species may be necessary to support the speciesâ conservation. While replacement of a rare or threatened species with a more common species or a species of lesser conservation concern (Curzer et al., 2013) may be more desirable in terms of conservation impacts, it does not address the Three Rs principle of replacement. To address the Three Rs principle of reduction in scientific activities that require live animals, the appropri- ate number of animals to provide valid information and the statistical power to support conclusions should be used, and these numbers should be supported by an appropriate power study or prior research. Good design of the scientific activity is the primary means of reducing the number of animals required to demon- strate outcomes in the field. Prior statistical evaluation of sample size is necessary, even when sources of vari- ation only can be roughly estimated. Familiarity with the literature on similar scientific activities regarding sample size and design is important. Reducing animal numbers can also be attained by cooperation between investigators in obtaining animal samples for their animal care committee-approved scientific activities, better sharing of data through data repositories, and publication of results in generally accessible formats. The primary focus of this guidelines document is on refinement, with the aim of minimizing disturbance, stress, pain, and distress to wildlife while undertaking approved scientific activities. The animalâs physical and psychological well-being should always take precedence over considerations of cost and convenience, Section 1 Introduction CCAC guidelines: Wildlife 12 while also taking into consideration human safety. In addition, refinement efforts should aim to use tech- niques that have the least potential to impede normal behaviours (e.g., using hair or fur traps that do not involve capture, using low-invasiveness tagging, minimizing handling time, reducing frequency of visits to nesting sites, or ensuring family groups are released together). When distressed, animals may behave abnor- mally and possibly be placed at greater risk of injury or predation. Excessive stress, whether acute and severe or prolonged and chronic, can reduce health, performance, immune function, and reproduction. Protocols must be developed to treat wildlife involved in scientific activities humanely, not only for ethical and legal reasons, but also for the quality of scientific results (Animal Behavior Society (ABS) and the Association for the Study of Animal Behaviour (ASAB), 1997)). In general, acceptable procedures should minimize inter- ference to individual animals, populations, and habitats, and thereby increase the validity of the data and results. Additionally, minimizing disturbance to the environment will reduce the number of other animals affected by the scientific activity. Guideline 1 Scientific activities that do not interfere with the animal in any way (e.g., observations from a distance that are unlikely to affect normal behaviour) should be prioritized over more intrusive approaches. Investigators should keep up to date with new techniques and implement them when they can reduce or eliminate the need for direct contact with animals. Examples include: ⢠using remote imagery to estimate seabird (Barber-Meyer et al., 2007) and polar bear (Stapleton et al., 2014) populations; ⢠using artificial intelligence and facial recognition software to identify individual bears without the need to capture and tag (Anderson et al., 2007; Clapham et al., 2020); ⢠identifying individual amphibians (Loafman, 1991; Eitam and Blaustein, 2002) and cetaceans (Hauser et al., 2006; Bergler et al., 2021) by scanning or photographing patterns; and ⢠understanding bird movement and migration through databases supported by citizen science observa- tions (Sullivan et al., 2009; Walker and Taylor, 2017). Scientific activities involving wildlife in the field and in captivity include a wide range of techniques that must be refined to accommodate the target species and their response to the presence of humans. The tre- mendous variation in size, physiology, and behaviours of animals needs to be taken into account to deter- mine the most effective means of capture, restraint, and handling. During the development of protocols and SOPs, investigators should consult those who have experience with the species and expertise in the proce- dures to maintain good animal welfare practices. Investigators and project personnel should be competent in the procedures they will be undertaking prior to the start of the scientific activity. 1.4 CONSIDERATIONS FOR ANIMAL CARE COMMITTEES Animal care committees that regularly deal with field-based projects should have two or more wildlife professionals with expertise in captive or free-ranging wildlife on the committee. Animal care committees that rarely review wildlife studies and do not have such expertise must consult wildlife professionals with relevant expertise when reviewing protocols involving wildlife. Given the wide range of species and methodologies Section 1 Introduction CCAC guidelines: Wildlife 13 employed in scientific activities involving wildlife, even animal care committees experienced with reviewing protocols involving wildlife may need to periodically consult additional wildlife professionals. When evaluating protocols for scientific activities that are to take place in the natural habitat of wild animals, animal care committees should recognize that conditions are likely to require different approaches, sample sizes, and procedures than those dictated by a laboratory environment or those used for domestic or semi- domesticated animals. Scientific activities in the field often require larger samples than in the laboratory to overcome natural attrition and environmental and individual variation that cannot be controlled in the field, and some scientific activities involving wildlife require marking and following complete populations, rather than a sample of those populations. Animal care committees should also be aware that protocols for testing devices or techniques that evaluate the most humane and effective methods for subsequent use may involve some unpredictability and flexibility. For these protocols, pilot studies may be important. It is important that the veterinarian on the animal care committee evaluates the need for veterinary involve- ment (i.e., direct involvement in procedures, oversight, training, and communication) in protocols, in line with provincial and territorial regulations and the welfare of the animals. Where field sites cannot be visited easily and procedures cannot be assessed or validated by members of the animal care committee in person as part of their post-approval monitoring (PAM) program, investigators should be prepared to photograph and record procedures and share these materials with the animal care committee for information and approval. Approved materials can be helpful in training other investigators and animal care committee members and in developing SOPs. Section 2 â Scientific Activities Conducted in the Field CCAC guidelines: Wildlife 14 2 SCIENTIFIC ACTIVITIES CONDUCTED IN THE FIELD 2.1 GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS Investigators must obtain all applicable permits prior to initiation of scientific activities and understand and comply with all regulations relevant to the jurisdiction and species involved. When working outside of Canada, Canadian investigators may be subject to additional regulations in the country where the scientific activity is conducted. Appendix 1 provides a starting point for consulting relevant regulations and authori- ties. Investigators should contact the appropriate authority for the most up-to-date permit requirements, as regulations and procedures may change over time. Investigators must ensure their use of live animals is in accordance with applicable permit terms, conditions, and guidelines. When a permit is required, the permit number under which an animal was collected should be retained by the investigator throughout the scientific activity to demonstrate that the sample was legally obtained. Publishers may also require permit numbers to be reported in the submission of journal articles. Investigators should take into account traditional or local knowledge and community values and, where appropriate, share knowledge gained through their scientific activities with the local community. The ben- efits of establishing a mutual exchange of information between investigators and stakeholders, including those with traditional knowledge, is well recognized by the International Council for Science (ICSU) and the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) (ICSU, 2002). In particu- lar, investigators should be aware that traditional knowledge may be considered intellectual property, and in such cases guidelines on intellectual property would apply (The First Nations Information Governance Centre, 2014). Collaborating with local people and organizations (e.g., guiding services, trappers) that ob- tained wildlife for other purposes (e.g., roadkill, hunted, trapped, culled) where the investigator is not in- volved in the collection process can provide access to wildlife and samples from wildlife for use in scientific activities as secondary data. Guideline 2 Scientific activities conducted in the field must be designed with the welfare of the animals in mind and to minimize disturbance of the animals and their habitat. The use of wildlife in science raises ethical concerns. Adequate review of protocols by animal care committees is critical to ensure that proposed field procedures and techniques minimize pain and distress, distortion of animal behaviour, changes to habitat, and other risks. Although the acquisition of scientific knowledge and understanding may justify a scientific activity involving wildlife, the effects of field procedures on animals or their habitats cannot always be predicted. Consideration must be given to the potential risks to animals and their populations and environment, and these risks must be weighed against the potential benefits of the scientific activity. 6 H F W L R Q h ² 6 F L H Q W L À F $ F W L Y L W L H V &